Which 56 Clemente to keep

[DJCollector1]

Originally Posted by GasHouseGang

I guess we are in the minority, but I like the SGC card better. The white of the border is so much brighter. It makes the PSA card look old and tired by comparison.

This comment and "Junky Joe's" are exactly why its hard to challenge grading, and opinion.
Everyone likes something slightly different.

Truth be known, I would be happy to own either of these two cards.
Actually, if you were to examine them, one day look at one, then the next day look at the other, you likely wouldn't see enough difference where you would actually have a massive preference.
The obsessive centering enthusiasts might pick the PSA, but I think like GasHouse mentions, the whiter border makes the SGC Clemente really pop off the screen.

Ignatius should be happy whichever one he chooses to keep.