opinion on these HOFers please

[khw]

i would be comfortable sending the cronin and aaron for sure , but yes beckett? i think then it may pass as good , pretty consistent there. to me on the scorecard adding extras on was value if it was in hand i could get a better idea of the ink , i have seem some weird stuff especially with albums and team pages . it just to me as a clubhouse things fall into some common sense, not as many clubhouse from this era as later ruth gehrig but i dont recall simmons rowe and guys like that having somebody to get that close to a signature vs just having somebody work all of those on behind closed doors, and how often does a scorecard end up getting taken into a clubhouse, handed into a dugout maybe but it isnt a team ball , and in a dugout more than likely they just wouldnt sign it vs having somebody sign for them , i remember years ago spence was looking at a yankees team ball and said so and so is a clubhouse and combes is his wife. what was she doing in the clubhouse?

[BillyCoxDodgers3B]

Simmons is terrible. Agreed, that score card is more trouble than it's worth. Leaning toward the rest being fine, but would like to have item in hand prior to saying more. Such an odd piece. The standard reasoning might suggest ink enhancement over original pencil signatures (that would really explain the awful Simmons), but that's not necessarily the case here. Regardless, impossible to give an accurate opinion based on such a scan.

Aaron is a very common vintage through the mail secretarial. I'm amazed nobody caught that.

[theshleps]

Thanks. Not ink over pencil, checked carefully for that. There are 2 or possibly 3 different inks involved. Greenberg is a stand alone ink. The others are the same color but 2 distinct widths which could be 2 separate pens. My son was a clubbie for a few years and signed for a scrub player at times and we know how at times some players signed for others- could have been in the dugout, unlikely in the clubhouse. I like the piece with a vintage Greenberg for sure and the Yankee section has DiMaggio, Gehrig, Lazzeri listed in the lineup. Even though they all could be good except Simmons I will probably list as a Greenberg/gehrig signed item as the JSA will say. I am just trying to let go of items slightly outside my collecting parameters as this is plus duplicates as these cards are.
Thanks for all the time and help