Mantle opinion please

[thetruthisoutthere]

That Mantle is authentic.

[Terrier8HOF]

Looks fine to me. In fact, very nice example.

[thetruthisoutthere]

Originally Posted by Terrier8HOF

Looks fine to me. In fact, very nice example.

Absolutely.

[Sophiedog]

Yes I agree that the Mantle is authentic. He cared when he signed and his placement was always right on. It's a card so it's not like he's got unlimited space to sign. Very nice example

[bobbyw8469]

I got a real one if you want to use it as an exemplar. I met him when I was 15.

[RedsFan1941]

nice mantle. a-OK!

[chaddurbin]

man i hang out on this side to get away from guys like bobby on the main board...why is he over here spewing his nonsense? go back over there and don't come back.

[ATP]

I'll weigh in. I think it's authentic. But, it's not typical for the most common type and could definitely throw folks off who might not study his signature quite in depth. From the ones I have owned, I am going to assume this one is late 1970's to maybe early 1980's? There was a period of time that the Mick signed with a really really small "y' in his first name and this is near that time. I personally would not have any issues buying or selling this example. No slight intended to anyone who has posted their opinion, but I have gotten railed on this before. People who don't really know autographs as their main area of expertise can post on forums and really affect both buyers and sellers. Just like the BST section on Net54, the autograph section is starting to become caveat emptor unless you know which are less empty than others.

[bobbyw8469]

I repeat...I met him when I was 15, so I can show what a real signature looks like. Chad Durbin you can kiss my ass!!!! My apologies that the M in Mickey look off!!! I didn't sign it! That alone gives me cause for concern. But if JSA said it was good, it MUST be, eh?

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

I repeat...I met him when I was 15, so I can show what a real signature looks like. Chad Durbin you can kiss my ass!!!! My apologies that the M in Mickey look off!!! I didn't sign it! That alone gives me cause for concern. But if JSA said it was good, it MUST be, eh?

I know very little about autographs so please explain to me how meeting him at 15 makes any difference. Was it a 1 time meeting or did you become personal friends and hang out all the time discussing how his autograph changed over time?

Please show your real autograph.