T206 Tinker To Evers To Chance Grade Opinon

[Luke]

No Chance that Evers gets even a 3.5 after seeing the close up pic. Just a nice looking VG card. Tinker will probably grade higher.

[btcarfagno]

The Evers has a slight notch in the right border. I would say 4 tops. Again...if not trimmed.

Tom C

[nsaddict]

It would be cool to see PSA do a larger holder for the trio, with individual flips. If there were enough interest they probably could do it. That would be a kick-ass display. Anybody good at photoshop and bored?

[AddieJoss]

Every card in a screw down holder is trimmed or fake!

[njdunkin1]

Good thoughts here from the Net54 members. Our consensus was voiced. If I have learned anything, it's that the majority of guys here are all well intended and speak honestly. If the average suggested is a 3.5, then it will hit pretty close to that grade unless trimmed. Either way, I'd go for it and get them graded. Can't hurt, right?
Regards,
NJ Dunkin

[Scocs]

No way the Evers gets an SGC 60. SGC 50/PSA 3.5-4 tops...

[Jantz]

I wouldn't be shocked to find that the Evers has been cleaned. The dark corners is a tell-tale sign.

The Evers is a 3. Maybe a 3.5 And if you want higher grades, tear some paper off the backs.