Mantle/DiMaggio/Williams Gateway Cachet Opinions

[39special]

If they are from Jim,they are good.

[Klrdds]

Agree 100% with the previous posts!

[earlywynnfan]

Ok, I'll bite. On a recent post, Travis showed how the T should flow into the L, not just go straight up and down. Also, the last name should not be on a straight line. He was applauded for his post.

The Mantle here has a T that goes straight down, and the last name is on a straight line.

Jim Stinson is my #1 favorite, most trustworthy seller in the hobby. So can someone show me what's up?

[thetruthisoutthere]

Originally Posted by earlywynnfan

Ok, I'll bite. On a recent post, Travis showed how the T should flow into the L, not just go straight up and down. Also, the last name should not be on a straight line. He was applauded for his post.

The Mantle here has a T that goes straight down, and the last name is on a straight line.

Jim Stinson is my #1 favorite, most trustworthy seller in the hobby. So can someone show me what's up?

"Applauded" for his post on a mass-produced Mantle forgery?

[travrosty]

This one is not on a straight line either, no matter how you slice it.

Happy to show specifics on autographs so people can learn.

[Ryan1125]

All 3 of these are authentic

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by thetruthisoutthere

"Applauded" for his post on a mass-produced Mantle forgery?

no, applauded for answering a specific question that is not PSA or JSA related... actually being a benefit instead of divisive on a blog. For the first time in 5 YEARS LOL.

He is good with those pics... and has tons of great info, when he CHOOSES to share and be empathetic, which ain't that often. I welcome the pics and the extra opinions. Especially, when he chooses to try and teach Mantle !~!

These 3 are all good IMHO, for whatever it's worth.

[kengoldin]

I believe all three are authentic
Gateway was well. Known for dealing directly with the athlete and when I had athletes such as Ripken, Ryan, Aaron , etc they would contract with us to purchase autographs and we would have their items signed in person.
Although it's possible, I cannot recall seeing a non authentic postmarked gateway . All three autos look period correct to me as well, and I certainly had a lot signed by these guys!

[dscards]

Update: Acquired and framed.