NAV: Ty Cobb autograph with Ironclad :) provenance

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by canjond

Scott-

Cool piece, and one point of clarification. I recall when these sold, there was mention of certain of the signatures being enhanced (and I believe the original JSA letters noted that). Was the enhancement the white you referenced, or was Ty's signature actually traced over to make it appear as bold as it does?

Obviously please don't take this question the wrong way - the answer obviously affects my level of interest.

Thanks.

One more thing. Here is the exact detail from the SCP auction. There was no image of the actual JSA letter shown in the auction. It sounds like you are a disgruntled consignor. If you truly thought the ink in Cobb's signature had been traced over, you should have made sure that the auction house divulged that when you consigned it. Same for the text from the JSA letter that I quoted. But SCP was spot-on with there description - detail pertaining to the Cobb autograph is highlighted below and corresponds almost exactly to my description. I wasn't even aware of the exact text from the JSA letter (I had not read it) until I went back to look for after your comment. Apparently you were the only one who had actually read it.

It's true that I got an unusually good deal on this lot. Bad form, Jon.

"Interesting collection of typed signed letters and partial letters to the Bradley Knitting Company in which 7 prominent managers agree, in exchange for 25 sweaters, to let them use their signature, a quote from him on how good the sweaters are, and a photo of their teams wearing the sweaters in their advertising. All have signed in beautiful 9/10 vintage black steel tip pen. Full letters are: William Killefer - Chicago Cubs, Bill McKechnie - Pittsburgh Pirates, George Sisler - St. Louis Browns, and Clark Griffith - Washington Senators. Partial letters(quote and signature): Ty Cobb - Detroit Tigers, Dave Bancroft - Boston Braves, and Art Fletcher - Philadelphia Phillies. All letters are in nice condition with the following minor exceptions: Killefer & McKechnie have rust stains from a paper clip, Griffith has 3 small stains to left side, Fletcher has a line of pencil writing. George Sisler has added an extra hand written paragraph to his letter. A little of the background to the Ty Cobb signature has been cleaned up to make a better image when replicated in advertising materials. Also included is a February 24, 1924 letter to the advertising manager of Baseball Magazine concerning the sending of these testimonials for publication. A great sampling of significant pre-war baseball autographs as well an interesting window into the early days of sports marketing.
All seven letters have individual full LOA's from JSA.
Lot has been Pre-certified by PSA/DNA."