Hello!

[YankeeFan]

Rob,

Welcome to Net54 and thanks for sharing a little of your story and those awesome pictures of your advanced Giants collection! You have done a great job with your displays and I am impressed that you have not only the walls covered, but the floor too!

Like your Dad, I'm from NJ too. But my Dad's allegiances fell on the other side of the river, so I ended up becoming a Yankees fan during the dry spell of the late 1960's.

You mentioned that you would like to share and expand your knowledge of Giants memorabilia. I don't mean to hijack your introductory post, but you have inspired me to share something in the hopes that you or some other knowledgeable collector could help shed some light.

I lived in Yonkers, NY for a few years; a stone's throw north of Yankee Stadium and the site of the old Polo Grounds. I met an old gentleman who was an avid fan of the NY Giants. He told me stories of going to many games with his Dad and brother, and how sad it made him when they moved.

He had a few mementos, but the only tickets he ever saved were the ones pictured below and a ticket to the July 4, 1941 Lou Gehrig Memorial game at Yankee Stadium. He told me about attending the last game at the Polo Grounds and that these were the tickets that he, his brother and Dad used to gain admission to that game! I believed him because he had no reason to lie to me and of all the games he went to in his life, he only deemed these important enough to save. Eventually, I convinced him to sell me all four of his tickets (these 3 and the Gehrig memorial).

The problem from a collector's point of view is that the tickets are not dated 1957. Which brings me, at last, to my point. Does anyone know of anything in the printing of these tickets that could confirm that they are or are not from 1957?

Any help would be appreciated.

[ooo-ribay]

Originally Posted by YankeeFan

The problem from a collector's point of view is that the tickets are not dated 1957. Which brings me, at last, to my point. Does anyone know of anything in the printing of these tickets that could confirm that they are or are not from 1957?

Any help would be appreciated.

I see your dilemma.... I thought I might be able to help, but I can't . I do have an idea though.....I have many, many SF Giants ticket "presale" booklets (mailed out in the off season) and I even have one from the NY Giants for the upcoming 1948 season. These list ticket prices. Maybe, Grand Stand admission was $1.30 for 1957 only. If you can prove this, you've dated the tickets!

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by YankeeFan

Rob,

Welcome to Net54 and thanks for sharing a little of your story and those awesome pictures of your advanced Giants collection! You have done a great job with your displays and I am impressed that you have not only the walls covered, but the floor too!

Like your Dad, I'm from NJ too. But my Dad's allegiances fell on the other side of the river, so I ended up becoming a Yankees fan during the dry spell of the late 1960's.

You mentioned that you would like to share and expand your knowledge of Giants memorabilia. I don't mean to hijack your introductory post, but you have inspired me to share something in the hopes that you or some other knowledgeable collector could help shed some light.

I lived in Yonkers, NY for a few years; a stone's throw north of Yankee Stadium and the site of the old Polo Grounds. I met an old gentleman who was an avid fan of the NY Giants. He told me stories of going to many games with his Dad and brother, and how sad it made him when they moved.

He had a few mementos, but the only tickets he ever saved were the ones pictured below and a ticket to the July 4, 1941 Lou Gehrig Memorial game at Yankee Stadium. He told me about attending the last game at the Polo Grounds and that these were the tickets that he, his brother and Dad used to gain admission to that game! I believed him because he had no reason to lie to me and of all the games he went to in his life, he only deemed these important enough to save. Eventually, I convinced him to sell me all four of his tickets (these 3 and the Gehrig memorial).

The problem from a collector's point of view is that the tickets are not dated 1957. Which brings me, at last, to my point. Does anyone know of anything in the printing of these tickets that could confirm that they are or are not from 1957?

Any help would be appreciated.

Hi Jack,
I can certainly vouch for the fact that these tickets are from the mid-late 1950's based on the numerical font and ticket price. I do believe that the last game in 1957 was game 77.

That being said, unless the patron wrote info on the ticket in pen or pencil, or the tickets were accompanied with a scorebook, program from the game it's tough to say these tickets are from precisely this game or game 77 from, say, 1955 or 1956.

I will try to keep an eye out for other tickets from this final game at NY Giants that come up for sale to give you a reference point.

I would tend to believe the man's story based on what you've described, BTW...

[YankeeFan]

Originally Posted by Scott Garner

Hi Jack,
I can certainly vouch for the fact that these tickets are from the mid-late 1950's based on the numerical font and ticket price. I do believe that the last game in 1957 was game 77.

That being said, unless the patron wrote info on the ticket in pen or pencil, or the tickets were accompanied with a scorebook, program from the game it's tough to say these tickets are from precisely this game or game 77 from, say, 1955 or 1956.

I will try to keep an eye out for other tickets from this final game at NY Giants that come up for sale to give you a reference point.

I would tend to believe the man's story based on what you've described, BTW...

Scott - Thank you for your comments and your confirmation that they are at least from the right time period. Although I personally do not doubt they are the 1957 tickets, I obviously have a vested interest in that position!

If you do come across any others for sale, I would certainly appreciate hearing about it. Thanks Again, Jack

[ethicsprof]

welcome aboard!!!
amazing collection!
all the best,
barry

[vintagesportflips]

Incredible Giants room Rob. Congrats!
Beautiful nodder display, and it's obvious that a ton of thought went into maximizing your wall and display space.
Welcome to the forum.

[doug.goodman]

As a Dodgers fan who grew up in Northern California and enjoyed seeing my favorite team (and plenty of others) at Candlestick Park, welcome to Net54.

Doug

[toyman55]

That is one fantastic display. I too am a Lifelong Dodger fan, but, I have some nice giants memorabilia as well. I have one room for my collection but your's is fantastic.