1947 D323 Tip Top Bread

[novakjr]

Originally Posted by timelord

I also think that the 1947 Tip Top Bread set has some true Rookie as you mentioned Berra, Spahn, and Kell. Great looking set also. Beckett rates 1948 Bowman Berra, Spahn and I believe the Leaf Kell as true rookies.
Thanks,
Richard

The Leaf wasn't a '48 issue. Often mislabeled as one though. As a '49 issue, it makes both that and the '49 Bowman, somewhat acceptable rookies for him. But yes, I'd say that the '47 is Kell's "true rookie card". I think he has the '45 team issue photo though. But that's debatable as if it's a "card" or not..

Don't forget Kiner... As the '46-49 Sports Exchange is both a larger premium, and may not even pre-date '47. As evident by the Bob Lemon in the Sports Exchange set, because there's not a chance in hell it can predate '49(while being shared with Red Rolfe as a Manager)...Although it often gets lumped at the front of the line for him, because the timespan of the issue starts in '46...