PSA Miscuts and Consistency

[mintacular]

This card is a straight 6:

http://cgi.ebay.com/1968-Topps-150-B...ht_1697wt_1139

And yet this one gets a MC qualifier, not even a O/C the worst it should be!

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...3#ht_500wt_922

Instead of complaining about possible misgrades here, I have a major problem with this, the Brooks gets a MC qualifier apparently the seller did not request "NQ" yet the Clemente gets a decent 6 grade--the seller must have requested as such.

The larger issue at hand is is that you the submitter can ask the TPG to give a "straight" grade even if a card is miscut...If the card is a miscut it is miscut and should be graded as such. The problem with this arrangement is that you have a situation where the Brooks is designated miscut but the Clemente is not...