Scrapbook Find - H812s? Keefe and Connor

[vintagesportflips]

I am usually more of a memoribilia collector and poster on the memoribilia side, but I recently picked up a scrapbook that has a wide variety of trade cards, scraps, flag etc tobacco cards, but it also has 2 interesting baseball pieces. They have the appearance of trimmed H812s, and in one of them you can make out the name Roger Connor at the bottom, the other I believe is Tim Keefe. They are approximately three inches tall. I believe based on net54 archives searching that REA sold 8 trimmed H812s about 15 years ago, 1 of which included Keefe even though he isn't listed on the checklists available online. What do you guys think? Are these H812s? or some other period piece? The other pieces in the scrapbook are definetly 1880s period.

Thanks
Keith
Here are some scans: