Group of Old Judges Being Sold on Ebay

[oldjudge]

Someone is selling a group of trimmed, colored Old Judges on Ebay. In the lot descriptions they quote vintagecardprices.com data for "similar" cards. Is this data accurate; the prices seem crazy to me? I have attached one of the descriptions for a Burch card.

"This card comes from an original collection of Old Judges (N172) that were once loved to the point that the borders were neatly trimmed and in some cases a name was neatly stamped on the back or handwriting in pencil of “1887” was written on the back, hence the SGC Authentic grade. Also, you can tell many decades ago, a previous owner had colored in small amounts on the front with a light red pen. This card is extremely rare and we have the following data from vintagecardprices.com to illustrate previous known sales. Free shipping within the U.S.; will ship internationally, email if interested.

Ernest Burch, Brooklyn variation, hands cupped high. No previous sales, extremely rare (leaning pose variation sold for $3,650.00 in SGC 10). "