I thought SGC didn't grade restored card?

[Archive]

Posted By: leon

I just spoke to an executive at SGC. Their stance is that if they missed something on this they will do anything the buyer of the card wants in so far as writing a check for a refund etc.....if they determine it was an error. I have no reason to doubt Rhys. That being said if the card was marked on and the marking was not meant for deception then it could feasibly grade a 1 (or 10). There is some gray area here (no pun intended) and I really don't want to get into the "they should" or "they shouldn't" grade this or that. The bottom line is that all grading is done by humans and humans will make mistakes. The part that seperates winners from losers is how those mistakes are dealt with. The buyer of this card, which I am told has been apprised of the situation, will still most likely keep it. It's his call and SGC will gladly, promptly refund his money if, it was an SGC mistake, and he wants to return it..David has also publicly said he will stand behind it....nuff said.....