After paying their dues, should hobbyists who committed fraud be allowed back ?

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by MailboxBaseball

I voted no.

To me Net54 is sort of a close knit community, almost a "baseball card family" of sorts, even though I'm sure many will consider that to be an overstatement.

Paying a debt to society is one thing, but learning from their mistakes and changing their lifestyles and mindset is completely a separate topic.

No one is saying these people shouldnt be allowed back into the hobby. They can buy, sell, or trade at any card show or other website in the world. But if they have defrauded people in the past, I think we should take at least the minimal steps to protect this special site.

Many of us have done some pretty insane deals over $10-grand on this site by paying via friends and family. When I tell my friends that, they ask "are you crazy???" haha.

If we don't have trust here when doing a deal, what do we have?

Simply being a member here does not automatically grant one trust though in the B/S/T forums. It still has to be earned. I've even sold cards to people that didn't know me at all and who weren't about to trust a new member, so I just sent them the cards and said, "pay me after you receive it if you like the card and want to keep it. If you don't, just send it back".