SGC to PSA Crossover Submission Results

[cmcclelland]

I thought some here might be interested in the results of a submission I just got back where I was trying to cross 56 pre-war cards from SGC to PSA. I wouldn't normally do this, but I plan to sell these and felt that the results would be better in a PSA holder, even if the grade was slightly lower in some cases. As noted below, I set the minimum grade below the original grade in some cases where I felt that the card might have been a bit "overgraded" and would probably sell better in the PSA holder, even if graded a half grade or a full grade lower. Overall, 43 of the 56 cards submitted crossed over (some at a half grade or full grade lower), which is better than I expected. I should also note that these were submitted on a monthly special on 12/10/18, and I just got the grades yesterday (4/26/19), which is obviously a ridiculously slow turnaround time but pretty much the new normal with PSA.

SGC
Card Grade Min Grade by PSA
1933 Goudey 240 Harold Schumacher 55 4 VG-EX 4
1933 Goudey 1 Benny Bengough 40 2 GOOD+ 2.5
1933 Goudey 41 Gus Mancuso 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 64 Burleigh Grimes 40 3 VERY GOOD 3
1933 Goudey 97 Joe Morrissey 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 113 Oswald Bluege 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 122 Alvin Crowder 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 129 Harold Schumacher 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 132 Jim Elliott 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 159 Oswald Bluege 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 196 Leroy Mahaffey 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 200 Bill Hallahan 60 4 VG-EX+ 4.5
1933 Goudey 57 Earl Clark 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 59 Bing Miller 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 61 Max Bishop 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 67 Guy Bush 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 69 Randy Moore 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 72 Owen Carroll 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 75 Willie Kamm 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 80 Clyde Manion 70 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 82 Dibrell Williams 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 83 Pete Jablonowski 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 85 Heinie Sand 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 90 Jess Petty 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 121 Walter Stewart 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1938 Goudey 256 Vernon Kennedy 80 5 EXCELLENT+ 5.5
1933 Goudey 20 Bill Terry 50 4 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1938 Goudey 287 Marvin Owen 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1938 Goudey 275 Bump Hadley 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1934 Goudey 59 Joe Mowry 80 5 EXCELLENT+ 5.5
1933 Goudey 174 Curley Ogden 82 6 EXCELLENT-MINT 6
1933 Goudey 16 George Blaeholder 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 11 Billy Rogell 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 33 Ralph Kress 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 215 Russell Van Atta 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 198 Jack Burns 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 182 Andy High 70 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 178 Jackie Warner 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 177 Walter French 70 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 172 Billy Hargrave 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1933 Goudey 162 Leo Mangum 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 146 Walter Stewart 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1933 Goudey 137 Red Lucas 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1938 Goudey 288 Bob Feller 40 3 VERY GOOD 3
1936 Diamond Stars 8 Joe Vosmik 84 6 EXCELLENT-MINT+ 6.5
1934 Diamond Stars 24 SparkyAdams 84 6 EXCELLENT-MINT 6
1935 Diamond Stars 61 Billy Werber 86 6 EXCELLENT-MINT+ 6.5
1935 Diamond Stars 69 Earl Grace 86 6 NEAR MINT 7
1935 Diamond Stars 78 Joe Kuhel 84 6 EXCELLENT-MINT+ 6.5
1935 Diamond Stars 79 Willis Hudlin 84 6 NEAR MINT 7
1935 Diamond Stars 84 Sam Byrd 84 6 EXCELLENT-MINT 6
1909 T206 Gus Dorner 50 4 VG-EX 4
1909 T206 Bill Hallman 60 5 MG: MINIMUM GRADE
1909 T206 Bob Rhoades-Hands Chest 60 5 EXCELLENT 5
1909 T206 Hal Chase Throwing Dark 30 2 GOOD 2
1927 Honey Boy 3 Carson McVey 30 2 GOOD 2