Hughie Jennings, Ty Cobb autographs; help needed!

[yanks12025]

Originally Posted by Econteachert205

At this point there is agreement on the Jennings being def good and the rest being absolutely period. The rest do not appear to have been done in the same hand, so that likely takes out the notion of it being a clubhouse/ old forgery. That would likely speak well for the bush and stanage. The cobb has elements that people like and others that are questionable. But it is early cobb and so there are likely still variations in the signature. I would say a likely possibility after looking more would be that minus the cobb the bat is good, and that the cobb is a toss up, maybe some better cobb experts can weigh in but I tried to look over variations and couldn't find an exact measurement with the t and c done in that manner.

Where is there a agreement that the Jennings is good???