OT - Who is the best player that should NOT be in the HOF?

[Archive]

Posted By: MikeU

I too believe he will get in, but what about Alomar, Richardson and Gordon? Some food for thought below:

Biggio has 4 Gold Gloves. Non-HOF'er 2nd basebmen with as many or more = Bobby Grich (4), Brett Boone (4), Bobby Richardson (5), Frank White (8) and Roberto Alomar (10). Others of interest = Keith Hernandez (11), Don Mattingly (9), Jim Kaat (16), Omar Vizquel (11), Dwight Evans (8), Andre Dawson (8).

Biggio has 4 Silver Slugger Awards. Non-HOF'er 2nd basemen with as many = Lou Whitaker (4), Jeff Kent (4), Juilio Franco (4), Roberto Alomar (4). Others of interest = Lance Parrish (6), Barry Larkin (9),

Biggio has 7 All-Star game appearances. Some Non-Hof'ers with as many or more appearances = Dick Allen (7), Roberto Alomar (12), Dave Concepcion (9), Walker Cooper (8), Del Crandall (9), Andre Dawson (8), Dom Dimaggio (7), Bill Freehan (11), Steve Garvey (10), Joe Gordon (9), Gil Hodges (8), Elston Howard (9), Bob Johnson (7), Ken Keltner (7), Harvey Kuenn (8), Barry Larkin (12), Sherm Lollar (7), Fred Lynn (8), Marty Marion (7), Edgar Martinez (7), Frank McCormick (8), Mark McGwire (12), Edward Miller (7), Minnie Minoso (7), Dale Murpy (7), Mike Mussina (7), Tony Oliva (8), Al Oliver (7), Dave Parker (7), Lance Parrish (8), Billy Pierce (7), Tim Raines (7), Jim Rice (8), Bobby Richardson (7), Ron Santo (9), Ted Simmons (8), Lee Smith (7), Reggie Smith (7), Vern Stephens (7), Dave Stieb (7), Darryl Strawberry (8), Joe Torre (9), Alan Trammell (7), James Vernon (7), Rudy York (7)

Career MVP Rankings: People ahead of Biggio not in Hall: Dave Parker, Jim Rice, Jeff Bagwell, Steve Garvey, Albert Belle, George Foster, Andrea Dawson, Dale Murphy, Pedro Guerrero, Don Mattingly, Vern Stephens, Keith Hernandez, Boog Powell, Mark McGwire, George Bell, Roberto Alomar, Frank McCormick, Minnie Minoso, Tony Oliva, Matt Williams, Will Clark, Maury Wills, Darryl Strawberry, Cecil Fielder, Larry Walker, Dick Allen, Ken Boyer, Joe Gordon and many more.