FS Mantle, Aaron, Mays

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by shammus

David,

Our rules are pretty clear on this. Your comment is critical of the card and has no place on the board as it is on the negative side and other prospective buyers may be influenced by your opinion. This sort of commentary may affect the sellers ability to sell the card, which is not allowed on our forum.

I understand your reasoning and desire to haggle in this case, however I would ask that next time you take it offline and send the seller a note directly so that other potential buyers aren't influenced. Much appreciated,

Brian

Really????

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...ighlight=bruce

That thread was on the B/S/T board, so how were folks allowed to make 215 (mostly) negative comments in that thread, but nothing was done? In other words, how do you pick and choose which threads to enforce your rules? Wasn't that the thread that got Bruce banned?

Let's just make this real easy though. Looking at the card, do YOU really believe it's NM+? I was a (potential) buyer based on the card's condition, not what some TPA said it to be. My offer still stands to buy the card based on the condition, not the flip. The fact that it's BVG graded lends absolutely no credibility to me (not knocking BVG, they just blew it on this one). Heck, in fact, if the seller wants to sell it based on condition rather than what's on the flip, he can even crack it out of the slab and ship it to me raw - save me from having to crack it out myself.

I made an offer based on condition. I've done nothing wrong here. I'm done arguing this. If it is still a problem, have Leon call me. He has my number.