Memory Lane Gehrig expectation vs reality

[gunboat82]

Originally Posted by Lucas00

Its really not hard to scan a card with zero clean up effects. I would recommend everybody scanning cards to not alter the scan settings at all.
The official SGC scan BARELY shows the crease, just checked.

Its hard sometimes, even unedited scans (like regular photos) hide flaws just because of the angle.

I can accept that they didn't doctor the scan. I asked for a refund because the description disclosed the horizontal crease at the bottom of the card (visible on the scan), but neglected to mention the massive fault line running down the middle of the card through the spot on Mantle's shoulder.

To their credit, Mile High refunded most of the purchase price, but for some reason decided to keep the 6.25% sales tax I paid.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

They mention the light horizontal crease but omit mention of the heavy vertical one? That's just weird.

[gunboat82]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

They mention the light horizontal crease but omit mention of the heavy vertical one? That's just weird.

They changed the description for the Extra Innings auction:

Deemed altered by SGC, the featured 1953 Topps Mickey Mantle card shows mostly lower to mid-grade features, centered adequately with rounded but consistent endpoints and a still stunning central image of the Yankees icon. The card does have several more prominent creases running vertically as well as left to right in the card.

At least the next buyer has a heads-up that the scan is misleading, I guess. I'm just out the $85.28 in sales tax paid, unless Brian planned to refund that separately. I sent a follow-up Tuesday and haven't heard back.

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by gunboat82

I can accept that they didn't doctor the scan. I asked for a refund because the description disclosed the horizontal crease at the bottom of the card (visible on the scan), but neglected to mention the massive fault line running down the middle of the card through the spot on Mantle's shoulder.

To their credit, Mile High refunded most of the purchase price, but for some reason decided to keep the 6.25% sales tax I paid.

good luck

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by gunboat82

I can accept that they didn't doctor the scan. I asked for a refund because the description disclosed the horizontal crease at the bottom of the card (visible on the scan), but neglected to mention the massive fault line running down the middle of the card through the spot on Mantle's shoulder.

To their credit, Mile High refunded most of the purchase price, but for some reason decided to keep the 6.25% sales tax I paid.

Wait, and they didn't even ban you from bidding in future auctions for return an item that was significantly not as described? WHOA! Madness!!

[gunboat82]

Originally Posted by Snowman

Wait, and they didn't even ban you from bidding in future auctions for return an item that was significantly not as described? WHOA! Madness!!

I might be banned and just didn’t get the memo yet.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by gunboat82

I might be banned and just didn’t get the memo yet.

Depending on the circumstances, Brian isn't going to ban someone for a justifiable problem with a lot.
.

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by Leon

Depending on the circumstances, Brian isn't going to ban someone for a justifiable problem with a lot.
.

Sounds like a company I could do business with.

[raulus]

Originally Posted by Snowman

Sounds like a company I could do business with.

Don't get cocky, kid!

I'm sure you'll do something to deserve it.