REA - dammit I'm out already

[Leon]

Originally Posted by becollie

It looks like I significantly overpaid for the E-90 Young but thrilled to finally pick up a version that at least looks to be well centered with strong registration. In my view one of the 5 most beautiful cards of all time and this will be my third time owning one ... hopefully the third time is the charm :-)

I agree. I own 2 and wouldn't mind another but nice ones have gone way up like everything else. That is a great example, damn the grade. Congrats

I struck out except for one small card, probably for resale.
.

[Casey2296]

"Oh, somewhere in this favored land the sun is shining bright;

The band is playing somewhere, and somewhere hearts are light,

And somewhere men are laughing, and somewhere children shout;

But there is no joy in Mudville—mighty Casey has struck out."


Congratulations to all the net54 members on their wins.

Now on to LOTG...

[mybuddyinc]

I was under bidder on 3 lots.

With the prices these days --- that's some sort of half-assed accomplishment ....

[Bobbycee]

Some of the T206 Cobbs went cheap, I thought. PSA 4.5 Bat Off for $10,500.
Red portrait 4.5 for $9,600. There were alot of Cobb choices but some bargains in there.

[MR RAREBACK]

One of my highlights was a 1887 n284 cap anson hard to believe they go that cheap

[babraham]

I managed to pick up two cards, a 1952 Bowman Mantle that has pretty good centering and a T200 Fatima Cleveland team card. The T200 is an upgrade to a PSA 1.5 that I currently have in my collection.

[cannonballsun]

Originally Posted by rjackson44

i won the catalog

Nice !

[mordecaibrown1]

Some beautiful pick ups. Figure I would join the Ruth Party.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Nada. Was only pursuing one card, a 56 Mantle, but it went into orbit and I gave up.

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by Bobbycee

Some of the T206 Cobbs went cheap, I thought. PSA 4.5 Bat Off for $10,500.
Red portrait 4.5 for $9,600. There were alot of Cobb choices but some bargains in there.

In my opinion price differential will vary greatly, even on the blue chip cards when factoring in centering, surface wear and overall eye appeal.

High eye appeal examples no matter the grade will always carry a premimum and sell for more than those examples which are just kinda blah!!

Thats my two cents on some of these from last night.

[Touch'EmAll]

Yes, eye appeal, especially centering seems to be a big factor in price these days.

There were 2 Cobb's Bat On, both PSA 4. One was 65/35 ish right/left and went for 9,900. The other looked at least 55/45 or better and went for 14,400.

[IndyDave]

Originally Posted by IndyDave

I’m down to one. Just upped the bid one more increment. Doubt it holds. We will see

Good luck to all

I was out shortly after I posted this - the lot of B18 blankets was my last one alive. I have a couple dozen and thought the lot of 41 would be a good way to grow my collection. I was about 50% under the winning bid so I wasn't even close.

[GeoPoto]

REA Lots #'s 326 and 327: T206 Freeman Old Mill: PSA 6 (Badly Centered): $690; PSA 5 (Well Centered): $900

[Vintageclout]

Originally Posted by Snapolit1

This letter is an amazing piece. I went to sleep leading at 17k and expected to lose later on for sure, but was stunned to see the final price. Would love to have this.

https://bid.robertedwardauctions.com...?ItemId=114610

Great piece! I was a player in the low 30’s and got crushed. Never thought it would sell for $50K all in.

[1880nonsports]

was hoping for a slight upgrade on my N43 Ewing...... 6500+ for a "50" looked quite a bit out of range at around 2am so I chose to fight another day. It was much easier to just go for it last REA with a large consignment that did well - I happily overpaid for my N162 along with the people who overpaid for my stuff.

[Schlesinj]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

pretty much anything Ruth or Jackson but main items were

1916 Sporting News Joe Jackson
1908 Rose Postcard Christy Mathewson
1926 Exhibit Ruth
1927 Exhibit Ruth
1922 e120 Caramel Ruth
1915 Ruth Photo
1923 Maple Crisp Ruth
1920 Societe Anonyme Ruth
1916 BF2 Felt Pennant Jackson
1913 Tom Barker Jackson

I was bidding on that Ruth type 2, but I lost steam. I did find the same photo (same stamp) on eBay for $20k obo. I think they list it as a 1916 photo. Not sure what year it was printed as this one from the 1930s.

[edhans]

Was hoping to win one or both of the E90-1 Wagners. Needless to say, I got neither. Underbidder on the batting and blown out of the water on the throwing. I'll probably just break up my set now.

[TigerMike]

Battled to the bitter end on the Wagners...ultimately just some others to chase for now. Ed let me know if you break your set up!

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by babraham

I managed to pick up two cards, a 1952 Bowman Mantle that has pretty good centering and a T200 Fatima Cleveland team card. The T200 is an upgrade to a PSA 1.5 that I currently have in my collection.

Very nice additions.

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by mordecaibrown1

Some beautiful pick ups. Figure I would join the Ruth Party. Seams like a lot of Ruth parties these days? May not be as nice as some of the other Ruths's but I liked it low pop and nice portrait. I was in on a few others but for one reason or another I jumped of them

Very nice addition on a tough Ruth!

[babraham]

I'm trying to pay my invoice to REA, but I never got emailed a copy of the invoice and my invoice in my website account just says this for payment types:

Please make checks payable to Robert Edward Auctions

If I remember correctly, the emailed invoices showed a lot more options for accepted payments. Would someone please be able to post or PM me the other options listed on their invoices? I emailed REA but haven't heard back yet.

Thank you for any help you can provide!

[MVSNYC]

Some fantastic pick ups...Ryan, the Brooklyn Atlantics card is a museum piece of the highest order.

I was happy to get this Wheat Red Hindu.

[carlsonjok]

I am happy, and slightly nauseous, with my pickup last night.



The most I have ever spent on a card before was about $400 and this came in at 5X that. But, as I mentioned on the Tell Me Some Good News thread, I landed a new job while still collecting severance checks from the previous one. I only needed 6 cards (including Clemente) to finish my 1955 set, so I decided to bite the bullet.

[paul]

I actually managed to pick up a card for what I thought was a bargain price -- the 1920 Zeenut Sam Crawford.

Everything else I was interested in went for at least double what I was willing to pay.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by paul

I actually managed to pick up a card for what I thought was a bargain price -- the 1920 Zeenut Sam Crawford.

Everything else I was interested in went for at least double what I was willing to pay.

I thought that was a good price to Paul.

[BobbyStrawberry]

Originally Posted by MVSNYC

Some fantastic pick ups...Ryan, the Brooklyn Atlantics card is a museum piece of the highest order.

I was happy to get this Wheat Red Hindu.

Very nice, MVSNYC. I was bidding on that one!

[brianclat11]

Stayed up late to get my first Goudy Ruth. I also landed the Cobb(Bat Off). They stretched the budget, but very happy to have them. Anyone else in on these?

item_112732_1_261725.jpg

item_113191_1_262651.jpg

[Casey2296]

Congrats on the pick ups Brian.

[brianclat11]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

Congrats on the pick ups Brian.

Thanks Phil. Always tough to know how high to go on some of these. I have been trying on both for a long time.

[Bobbycee]

Originally Posted by babraham

I'm trying to pay my invoice to REA, but I never got emailed a copy of the invoice and my invoice in my website account just says this for payment types:



If I remember correctly, the emailed invoices showed a lot more options for accepted payments. Would someone please be able to post or PM me the other options listed on their invoices? I emailed REA but haven't heard back yet.

Thank you for any help you can provide!

Brian:

Thank you for bidding at Robert Edward Auctions. Payments are due by August 29, 2022. Please remit payment by Zelle, bank wire, check, or money order to the address above. Zelle payments can be sent to bdwyer@robertedwardauctions.com or 908-500-6989. Please e-mail for wire instructions. We are currently accepting consignments for our upcoming auctions.
Please make checks payable to Robert Edward Auctions

[babraham]

Originally Posted by Bobbycee

Brian:

Thank you for bidding at Robert Edward Auctions. Payments are due by August 29, 2022. Please remit payment by Zelle, bank wire, check, or money order to the address above. Zelle payments can be sent to bdwyer@robertedwardauctions.com or 908-500-6989. Please e-mail for wire instructions. We are currently accepting consignments for our upcoming auctions.
Please make checks payable to Robert Edward Auctions

Great thank you! Appreciate it.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by brianclat11

Thanks Phil. Always tough to know how high to go on some of these. I have been trying on both for a long time.

Auction night justification is always fun.

1. Do I really need a new kitchen remodel?
2. How much of a loan can I get on my 401K?
3. Do my kids really need to go to a 4 year overpriced college?
4. Argh, why don't these auction houses take credit cards!
5. How much can I really sell a kidney for?
6. No! Male prostitution is out of the question.
7. Why couldn't I have just inherited money?
And my favorite:
8: Jesus, did I really overpay for that Cobb/Ruth/Jackson? I'll find a way to make it work...

[jayshum]

I was happy to pick up the last card I needed to complete my 1971 Topps Greatest Moments set - Tony Perez.

[brianclat11]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

Auction night justification is always fun.

1. Do I really need a new kitchen remodel?
2. How much of a loan can I get on my 401K?
3. Do my kids really need to go to a 4 year overpriced college?
4. Argh, why don't these auction houses take credit cards!
5. How much can I really sell a kidney for?
6. No! Male prostitution is out of the question.
7. Why couldn't I have just inherited money?
And my favorite:
8: Jesus, did I really overpay for that Cobb/Ruth/Jackson? I'll find a way to make it work...

Too funny! This list sums it up. When you have the fever, all options are on the table and rational thinking goes out the window.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by jayshum

I was happy to pick up the last card I needed to complete my 1971 Topps Greatest Moments set - Tony Perez.

Congrats Jay, awesome accomplishment. Someone went hard on the 71 TGM Munson last night.

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

Congrats Jay, awesome accomplishment. Someone went hard on the 71 TGM Munson last night.

Thanks, Phil. Perez went for more than I was hoping (isn't that always the case), but I really wanted to finish off the set.

The Munson ($2040) went cheap compared to the Bench ($3720).

[brianclat11]

Originally Posted by jayshum

Thanks, Phil. Perez went for more than I was hoping (isn't that always the case), but I really wanted to finish off the set.

The Munson ($2040) went cheap compared to the Bench ($3720).

What an awesome set. Congrats!

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by jayshum

Thanks, Phil. Perez went for more than I was hoping (isn't that always the case), but I really wanted to finish off the set.

The Munson ($2040) went cheap compared to the Bench ($3720).

Tough numbers when they used to be 700-900 for NM 7s but that's the way it is right now.

[LOUCARDFAN]

The one item I was able to pick up. Really wanted the other one that I kept bidding on but eventually realized that sleep was more important at almost 2am.

[chadeast]

Originally Posted by brianclat11

Stayed up late to get my first Goudy Ruth. I also landed the Cobb(Bat Off). They stretched the budget, but very happy to have them. Anyone else in on these?

Attachment 529915

Attachment 529916

Nice looking #144! I think you did well, especially considering the market these days. I was hoping the '33 Goudey Ruth #53 SGC 30 might slip through due to the mark on the back, that kind of card is normally right in my wheelhouse. But it went into the stratosphere. Guessing there's a decent chance that $24k may be the record for any 1933 Goudey graded 2 or less (not counting the pseudo-1933 Lajoie of course).

[DPassner1]

I won the PSA 5 1956 Koufax auto. Only one higher iirc . I decided to go one bid higher when I saw what the Greenberg Goudey auto was at. (Gonna be selling it as I have a high grade 56 Koufax and a later Topps auto in the PC.)

Also won one of the Polar Bear Admiral Schlei and the PSA 8 Dooin Herpolsheimer (which is the only 8 iirc?)

Thought all three were steals, but what I really wanted was the Maruzen Berg which became a last second bidding war. Now that I know it exists I'll have to nab one for my PC from someone or somewhere.
I also was high on the Swift Meats set, but dropped at 4100. I can imagine that PSA 10 Robinson getting 3k+

[brianclat11]

Originally Posted by chadeast

Nice looking #144! I think you did well, especially considering the market these days. I was hoping the '33 Goudey Ruth #53 SGC 30 might slip through due to the mark on the back, that kind of card is normally right in my wheelhouse. But it went into the stratosphere. Guessing there's a decent chance that $24k may be the record for any 1933 Goudey graded 2 or less (not counting the pseudo-1933 Lajoie of course).

Thanks Chad! It is always nice to get some confirmation on a purchase like that. The #53 surprised me as well. I was in early on that one as well until it shot to the moon.

[cubman1941]

I did manage to get a 53 Topps Paige. Will never finish the set but this will make a nice addition.

[mrreality68]

Some Great Pickups Everyone

Congrats

Gosh.....I feel left out....

[fkm_bky]

That is a stunning Cobb for a “2”. Congratulations!

Bill

Originally Posted by LOUCARDFAN

The one item I was able to pick up. Really wanted the other one that I kept bidding on but eventually realized that sleep was more important at almost 2am.

[Golfcollector]

Originally Posted by paul

I actually managed to pick up a card for what I thought was a bargain price -- the 1920 Zeenut Sam Crawford.

Everything else I was interested in went for at least double what I was willing to pay.

Great Card, I already have this one but still looking for any other crawford Zeenuts!

[becollie]

Mistaken Post

[becollie]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

That Young was, in my opinion, hands down the best looking card in the auction. I am sorry to admit that I was the underbidder and likely cost you some money, and I almost went back at it again. Congratulations on grabbing a gorgeous example of a key card.

Josh, great pick-up. Not too shabby either!

Red- nice pickup. Those Scrappss are very cool

Octovia- LOL. Enjoy. I am happy to give you mind. In fact, I tried to opt out of getting a catalog and I could not figure out of I could. I would be happy if you got mine and then you would have two

Haha ... no worries at all ... I am sure the consignor is happy ... now I just need to find a well centered E90 Speaker. The hunt begins :-)

[puckpaul]

I won only one card, this N173 Dan Stearns. Been looking for it for many years. Was surprised it didn’t run a lot higher. (The back is totally fine.)

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

Some Great Pickups Everyone

Congrats

Gosh.....I feel left out....

I’m sure we will see a awesome piece from you soon. Added you on instagram by the way baberuthcollector account.