List of cards that have player designated as playing for a Federal League team

[brianp-beme]

A few years back a thread ended up producing some good lists of various sets issued in 1914 and 1915 that contain cards of players with Federal League team designations. For reference, here is a link to that thread:

https://www.net54baseball.com/showth...hlight=federal

Being that we are currently visually deprived of our normal dose of baseball card imagery, I decided to comb through and research to see if any more Federal Leaguers during the leagues two year stint were hiding out there. I did find a fair amount in the sets that were not included in the other thread's lists (kidnapped18 and jjbond were the two posters that provided the bulk of the information, along with a bunch of other contributors). Many of these were pose variations, but also some that went unnoticed. In the process, I decided, utilizing their great lists, to redo and gussy up things with bold and underline emphasis (!), and post it as a cohesive entity, full of elan and mustard.

Just seeing if you were still with me. Feel free to post about changes/additions/subtractions/other sets not included, or just plain stupidity on my part, and we can shape this up to be a handy guide for those interested in the Federal Leagues. I have grouped each set by team to make it easier for team collectors to spot what is available for these somewhat oddly named teams.

Brian


1914 D303 GENERAL BAKING (12 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (3)
Chief Bender - striped hat
Mickey Doolan
Fred Jacklitsch

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (1)
Danny Murphy

Buffalo Blues (2)
Hal Chase - portrait
Clyde Engle

Chicago Whales (2)
Joe Tinker - batting
Joe Tinker - portrait

Kansas City Packers (1)
George Stovall

Newark Peppers (1)
Germany Schaefer

Pittsburgh Rebels (1)
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (1)
Eddie Plank - no position on front


1915 E106 AMERICAN CARAMEL (16 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (5)
Chief Bender - striped hat
Chief Bender - white hat
Mickey Doolan
Fred Jacklitsch
Otto Knabe

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (1)
Danny Murphy

Buffalo Blues (3)
Hal Chase - fielding
Hal Chase - portrait
Clyde Engle

Chicago Whales (2)
Joe Tinker - batting
Joe Tinker - portrait

Kansas City Packers (1)
George Stovall

Pittsburgh Rebels (1)
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (2)
Al Bridwell
Eddie Plank

Newark Peppers (1)
Germany Schaefer (Newark)


1914 E145-1 CRACKER JACK (39 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (4)
1 Otto Knabe
90 Frank Smith
113 George Suggs
120 Mickey Doolan

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (6)
9 Artie Hoffman
74 Frank Owens
81 Jim Delehanty
100 Tom Seaton
128 Steve Evans
140 Daniel F. Murphy

Buffalo Blues (4)
83 Russ Ford
107 Tom Downey
124 Earle Moore
126 Walter Blair

Chicago Whales (6)
3 Joe Tinker
13 Art Wilson
60 Rollie Zeider
76 Claude Hendrix
115 Ad Brennan
116 Rollie Zeider

Indianapolis Hoosiers (4)
20 Cy Falkenberg
24 George Mullen
98 Frank LaPorte
137 Bill Rariden

Kansas City Packers (4)
11 George Stovall
117 Ted Easterly
119 George Perring
142 Eugene Packard

Pittsburgh Rebels (5)
16 Howie Camnitz
59 Harry Gessler
84 Elmer Knetzer
139 Rebel Oakes
141 Cy Barger

St. Louis Terriers (6)
5 Ward Miller
25 Michael Simon
32 Mordecai Brown
42 Al Bridwell
46 Bob Groom
67 Otis Crandall


1915 E145-2 CRACKER JACK (50 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (5)
1 Otto Knabe
19 Chief Bender
90 Frank Smith
113 George Suggs
120 Mickey Doolan

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (8)
9 Artie Hoffman
43 Rube Marquard
74 Frank Owens
81 J. C. Delehanty
100 Tom Seaton
128 Steve Evans
140 Daniel F. Murphy
147 Lee Magee

Buffalo Blues (5)
83 Russ Ford
99 Hal Chase
107 Tom Downey
124 Earl Moore
126 Walter Blair

Chicago Whales (5)
3 Joe Tinker
13 Art Wilson
60 Rollie Zeider
76 Claude Hendrix
115 Ad Brennan

Indianapolis Hoosiers (8) - team moved for 1915 season to Newark and known as the Peppers, all cards designated Indianapolis
20 Cy Falkenberg
24 George Mullen
98 Frank La Porte
137 Bill Rariden
157 George Kaiserling
160 Benny Kauff
161 Edd Roush
168 Vin Campbell

Kansas City Packers (4)
11 George Stovall
117 Ted Easterly
119 George Perring
142 Eugene Packard

Pittsburgh Rebels (7)
16 Howie Camnitz
40 Jimmy Austin
59 Harry Gessler
84 E.E. Knetzer
118 Ed Konetchy
139 Rebel Oakes
141 Eros Barger

St. Louis Terriers (8)
5 Ward Miller
6 Eddie Plank
25 Michael Simon
32 Mordecai Brown
42 Al Bridwell
46 Bob Groom
67 Otis Crandall
127 Armando Marsans


1914-16 T213-2 COUPON (40 or 41 total) - pose information provided when more than one T206 pose variation issued

Baltimore Terrapins (8)
Chief Bender - no trees
Chief Bender - with trees
Mickey Doolan - batting
Mickey Doolan - fielding
Otto Knabe
Jack Quinn
Frank Smith - white cap
Kaiser Wilhelm - with bat

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (8/9)
Bill Bradley - batting
Bill Chappelle
Steve Evans
Sol Hofman
Danny Murphy - with bat
Ed Reulbach - no glove (currently unverified)
Ed Summers
Hooks Wiltse - portrait with cap
Hooks Wiltse - throwing

Buffalo Blues (5)
Hal Chase - holding trophy
Hal Chase - portrait
Hal Chase - throwing
Tom Downey - batting
Horace Ford

Chicago Whales (2)
Joe Tinker - bat off shoulder
Joe Tinker - bat on shoulder

Indianapolis Hoosiers (1)
George Mullin - batting

Kansas City Packers (3)
Red Murray
Germany Schaefer - throwing
George Stovall - batting

Newark Peppers (1)
George Mullin - batting

Pittsburgh Rebels (7)
Cy Barger
Howie Camnitz - arm down
Howie Camnitz - arms up
Ed Konetchy - glove low
Ed Lennox
Mike Mowrey
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (5)
Al Bridwell - with cap
Mordecai Brown - Chicago on uniform
Doc Crandall - portrait with cap
Bob Groom
Ed Willett - throwing


1915 T214 VICTORY (23 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (6)
Chief Bender - no trees
Chief Bender - with trees
Mickey Doolan
Jack Quinn
Frank Smith
Kaiser Wilhelm

Buffalo Blues (4)
Hal Chase - portrait
Hal Chase - throwing
Tom Downey
Russ Ford

Chicago Whales (2)
Joe Tinker - bat off
Joe Tinker - bat on

Indianapolis Hoosiers (1)
George Mullin

Kansas City Packers (2)
Germany Schaefer
George Stovall

Newark Peppers (1)
George Mullin

Pittsburgh Rebels (4)
Howie Camnitz
Ed Konetchy glove low
Ed Lennox
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (3)
Al Bridwell
Doc Crandall
Bob Groom


1911-1916 T216 PEOPLE'S TOBACCO KOTTON/MINO/VIRGINIA EXTRA (17, and 51 total from all 3 backs)

Baltimore Terrapins (5)
Chief Bender - striped hat
Chief Bender - white hat
Mickey Doolan
Fred Jacklitsch
Otto Knabe

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (1)
Danny Murphy

Buffalo Blues (3)
Hal Chase - portrait
Hal Chase - throwing
Clyde Engle

Chicago Whales (2)
Joe Tinker - batting
Joe Tinker - portrait

Kansas City Packers (1)
George Stovall

Newark Peppers (1)
Germany Schaefer

Pittsburgh Rebels (1)
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (3)
Al Bridwell - batting
Al Bridwell - sliding
Eddie Plank


1914 T330-2 PIEDMONT ART STAMPS (25 or 26 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (3/4)
Michael Doolan
Jack Quinn
George Suggs
Kaiser Wilhelm (currently unverified)

Brooklyn Tip-Tops (3)
Jim Delahanty
Steve Evans
Danny Murphy

Buffalo Blues (5)
Walter Blair
Al Bridwell
Tom Downey
Russ Ford- black cap
Russ Ford - white cap

Chicago Whales (2)
Fred Beck
Joe Tinker

Indianapolis Hoosiers (1)
Frank LaPorte

Kansas City Packers (1)
George Stovall

Pittsburgh Rebels (5)
Cy Barger
Howie Camnitz
Davy Jones
Ed Lennox
Rebel Oakes

St. Louis Terriers (5)
Al Bridwell
Mordecai Brown
Otis Crandall
Bob Groom
Ed Willett


1913-1915 W530 PINKERTON (1 total)

Chicago Whales (1)
208 Joe Tinker, Mgr.



1914 WG4 POLO GROUNDS GAME (2 total)

Chicago Whales (2)
Claude Hendrix - HIT
Claude Hendrix - STRIKe


1916 TANGO EGGS (1 total)

Newark Peppers (1)
Germany Schaefer


1915 POSTACO STAMPS (4 total)

Baltimore Terrapins (1)
Chief Bender

Chicago Whales (3)
Max Flack
Claude Hendrix
Joe Tinker


1914 E & S POSTCARD (1 total)

Kansas City Packers (1)
George Stovall


1914 BALTIMORE NEWS SCHEDULE **INCOMPLETE LIST?**(4 total)

Mike Doolin
Hack Simmons
George Suggs
Ducky Yount
Guy Zinn

[Casey2296]

Thanks for cleaning up the list Brian. You can add a Konetchy glove low to the T214 Victory Pittsburgh Fed. list, see post one in this months pick up thread.

[4815162342]

Brian, you can also add the D303 Hal Chase Catching pose to the list.

[tiger8mush]

Do supplements count?

[Brent G.]

This is fantastic, thank you! As an Indianapolis collector, I had no idea about the George Mullin T213, T214, or Frank LaPorte T330. If anyone has one of these to spare, please let me know!

[Spike]

Max Flack's an interesting case, as not only did his 1915 Postaco card show his Federal League status, close inspection of all of his 1916-22 cards show him in Chicago Feds/Whales uniforms! It would take until 1923 for Flack to be shown in an MLB uniform.

[orioles70]

Among the way too many things I collect is the 1914 T330-2 Piedmont Art Stamps set. I have about 50 stamps from this set. Of those I have 9 that show a Federal League designation...I have at least 1 representative from each of the 8 teams except the Chicago Whales. They are as follows with pic verification:

Baltimore Terrapins
Quinn

Brooklyn Tip-Tops
Delahanty

Buffalo Blues
Blair
Downey
Ford - white cap variation

Indianapolis Hoosiers
LaPorte

Kansas City Packers
Stovall

Pittsburgh Rebels
Jones

St. Louis Terriers
Crandall

I have a couple of observations.

1) I have a stamp of Otis Crandall with St. Louis Feds shown on front.
This stamp is not in your checklist.

2) I have 2 stamps of Chief Bender...both have Phila. Am on front.
You have Bender on your list as a Baltimore Terrapin...can you provide a pic of this variation?

Thanks
John Bowden


Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk

[brianp-beme]

Thanks Phil, Daryl, Rob, Matthew, and John for your comments and potential changes to the list. I have added the T214 Victory Konetchy glove low, the D303 General Baking Chase fielding, and the T330-2 Piedmont Art Stamps of Crandall St. Louis Terriers to the list. I have also deleted the T330-2 of Bender with Baltimore Terrapin designation from the list.

And now the confession. I utilized the Trading Card Database while researching for this newly invigorated list. Because of time constraints, I only checked the teams that the TCDb site designated for each card, and not the image provided to confirm the actual team designation on the card. For example, on their site they have T330-2 Bender on their list with a Baltimore designation, but the image shown has the Philadelphia designation. And the Crandall is listed as a New York Giant, but the image shows the stamp designation for him to be the St. Louis Feds (Terriers).

When I do have the time I plan to go through the entire Federal League list I created and check the images provided on the TCDb site to identify any other descrepancies, as well as, where necessary, attempt to track down images of those not on their site. While quickly checking, I did notice that the T330-2 of Wilhelm that they have on their list, identified as a Baltimore Terrapin, has as far as I know has not be verified to exist (hence the reason why no image is provided on their site for this one). I will mark it on the list as "currently unverified".

As far as suppliments, I think I will hold off on their inclusion, but certainly I nice example and perfectly collectible.


Brian

[brianp-beme]

I had the opportunity to check what I could, and have made revisions to the list on the original post.


I added five additional T214 Victory cards: Bender - no trees Baltimore, Bender - with trees Baltimore, Schaeffer - Kansas City, Tinker - bat off Chicago, Tinker - bat on Chicago.

I also added Bridwell - sliding St. Louis to T216 listing.

I removed two cards from the D303 listing: Bender - white cap, and Plank - position on front


Also I reorganized the groupings to make them in alphabetical ACC order.


Let me know if anything seems squinky.


Brian

[orioles70]

Brian...your diligence and dedication to this project is appreciated.

Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by tiger8mush

Do supplements count?

If they do there is a Whales Team m113, but I haven't figured out how to post flickr based photos...

[nolemmings]

Nice work Brian. You can add Hack Simmons to the Baltimore News list.

[brianp-beme]

Thanks all, and Todd, the Hack Simmons has been added. Always open to all input. Still thinking about the supplement option. It is a category of prewar I have never really considered.


Brian