Pretty sure these are fake. can you confirm?

[dj]

Got this from a guy who says he got it from an estate sale. Looking at known real ones they look fairly close but with some definite differences. Also can anyone tell me what the other one is supposed to be? i can make out Tom Glavine, John Smoltz, and Steve Avery.

[baseball tourist]

The other one is Greg Maddux

[dj]

Really? Man i dont think it looks close to any of the Greg Maddux. Not saying you're wrong i just mean it must be a terrible fake. Am i wrong in thinking these are definitely fakes?

[baseball tourist]

Originally Posted by dj

Really? Man i dont think it looks close to any of the Greg Maddux. Not saying you're wrong i just mean it must be a terrible fake. Am i wrong in thinking these are definitely fakes?

Sorry, can’t give you an opinion if these are authentic or not, just wanted to point out that the unknown one looks like Maddux. Fake? Rushed? Don’t know.

[dj]

Originally Posted by baseball tourist

Sorry, can’t give you an opinion if these are authentic or not, just wanted to point out that the unknown one looks like Maddux. Fake? Rushed? Don’t know.

thanks for your input

[Klrdds]

Yes . It is an attempt at Greg Maddux . I'm not comfortable with any of those signatures although the Glavine is a close early career attempt . None of the signatures look good to me FWIW .

[dj]

Originally Posted by Klrdds

Yes . It is an attempt at Greg Maddux . I'm not comfortable with any of those signatures although the Glavine is a close early career attempt . None of the signatures look good to me FWIW .

Thanks that's pretty much what i thought