Any idea why Johnny Mize doesn't have a 1938 Goudey or any Play Ball cards?

[Luke]

Seems really odd with how good he was at the time. Led the NL in HRs in 1939 and 1940.

[G1911]

Presumably because 1) Mize did not sign a contract with them and 2) he was a litigious fellow. He is said to have sued Gum Products, Inc. over the Double Play series in 1941 and put an end to the product from the court costs. I have not seen a primary source record of the case, only secondary claims but I don't follow the 40's issues really.

[jason.1969]

Originally Posted by G1911

Presumably because 1) Mize did not sign a contract with them and 2) he was a litigious fellow. He is said to have sued Gum Products, Inc. over the Double Play series in 1941 and put an end to the product from the court costs. I have not seen a primary source record of the case, only secondary claims but I don't follow the 40's issues really.

You will find an excellent write-up here, including citations at the bottom. https://sabrbaseballcards.blog/2022/...gation-part-i/


Jason
Twitter: @heavyj28

[jingram058]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

You will find an excellent write-up here, including citations at the bottom. https://sabrbaseballcards.blog/2022/...gation-part-i/


Jason
Twitter: @heavyj28

Indeed, quite excellent. Says it all.

[FrankWakefield]

Greg, Jason...

You guys nailed that with "walk off" responses.

Collectively, this board knows just about everything about old cards.

[Luke]

Wow, such great info, thank you!

[G1911]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

You will find an excellent write-up here, including citations at the bottom. https://sabrbaseballcards.blog/2022/...gation-part-i/


Jason
Twitter: @heavyj28

Thank you, I will look up the original articles, nice to see several of them already found and cited. Seems to me your friends article mostly confirms the general story that has floated around for a long time, except for perhaps the bit about Mize's losing lawsuit leading to expenses that caused Gum Products to cease making cards. Seems like with this speedy resolution it likely cost them very little and the war paper issues might be a more likely candidate for the lack of a follow up. Really interesting piece outside of this specific suit too

[jingram058]

I don't have any Mize cards in my collection and, frankly, don't want any. Likewise Terry Moore. Not a fan of Solly Hemus or Enos Slaughter either. You can keep that whole era of Cardinals for the most part, as far as I'm concerned.

[tedzan]

Back in 1982, my booth at the NJ Meadowlands BB card Show was next to Johnny Mize's booth.

We had a great time together, a really great guy. He invited me to his home in Georgia, if I was
in the area. In 1986, I was driving down to Florida, and did visit with Johnny at his home.
really great experience.


TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[CurtisFlood]

Originally Posted by jingram058

I don't have any Mize cards in my collection and, frankly, don't want any. Likewise Terry Moore. Not a fan of Solly Hemus or Enos Slaughter either. You can keep that whole era of Cardinals for the most part, as far as I'm concerned.

LOL, you sound like a guy who hates a certain team. All fine fellows, except Hemus.

[jason.1969]

Thanks, guys. My bud John won the SABR McFarland Award for his series of articles on baseball card litigation. This was just the first of four installments.


Jason
Twitter: @heavyj28