Pinback collectors – do you replace missing pins?

[Vintagedeputy]

A few times now I have purchased baseball pinback buttons that were missing the original pin. I feel like the button itself and what is on the front is much more important than the pin on the back.

Luckily, I have an antique store locally that has a huge tray of various sized and aged pinback buttons. I will usually just measure what size I need and will go to the store and find a crappy, period appropriate replacement, and will fix my button. This Skateland button for example was trashed but for $1, it was well worth grabbing the pin.

Does anyone else do this or does anyone see a problem with this since the pin is not original to the button?

[Hankphenom]

why not? I'm sure some would disagree, but as a pin guy I would put that in the "no big deal one way or the other" category. What I'm not crazy about is taking an old pin and adding newer ribbons and other items to make it something it never was. I'm a big fan of vintage pins with great hanging stuff that were sold that way originally, and avoid the newly created varieties like the plague. I'm guessing there are many newbie pin collectors who can't tell the difference, and it strikes me as an attempt to deceive to at least some extent on the part of those dealers who do that.

[Vintagedeputy]

Originally Posted by Hankphenom

why not? I'm sure some would disagree, but as a pin guy I would put that in the "no big deal one way or the other" category. What I'm not crazy about is taking an old pin and adding newer ribbons and other items to make it something it never was. I'm a big fan of vintage pins with great hanging stuff that were sold that way originally, and avoid the newly created varieties like the plague. I'm guessing there are many newbie pin collectors who can't tell the difference, and it strikes me as an attempt to deceive to at least some extent on the part of those dealers who do that.

I agree on both counts, Hank. I just wasn't sure if it was against some pinback etiquette to replace missing pins.

Adding stuff to pins that wasn't there originally seems different though, and wrong.

[Hankphenom]

Originally Posted by Vintagedeputy

Adding stuff to pins that wasn't there originally seems different though, and wrong.

And is done a LOT these days.

[Vintagedeputy]

Originally Posted by Hankphenom

And is done a LOT these days.

Very troubling, indeed.

[batsballsbases]

Jim No problem replacing lost pins as its very common to find them missing just as long as you use an older vintage pins in its replacement... just like you did,,,good job....