Old Judge Scrapbook Page

[Shoeless Moe]

So the winner of this auction:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/36394141859...rdt=true&rt=nc

for $5109

Now is immediately selling them, starting at $6500 (no bids yet)

https://www.ebay.com/itm/11550498790...Bk9SR4DCmqncYA

What's their value once soaked off the page?

Did he make a wise investment at 5100.......although plus tax it's a bit more.

[trdcrdkid]

I would NOT try to soak an Old Judge off a scrapbook page. You might soak the photograph off the cardboard backing instead, and then you just have a skinned Old Judge. Plus, even if you do successfully soak a card off a page, you need to press it under books or other weights while it dries, and I would be wary of doing that to an Old Judge, given the tendency of the cardboard to curl, and potentially to crack or crease if a weight is put on it.

[bigfish]

It looks like they have already been attempted to be removed. Then pasted back in. The lone jack card is cool.

[sb1]

Old brown horse glue, they weren't coming off....

[Directly]

If lone jack card would grade a PSA-1 would the card be valued in the $3,000 range?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Directly

If lone jack card would grade a PSA-1 would the card be valued in the $3,000 range?

I was interested in the lot for that card, of course. But if I am going to have one as a type card that one wasn't nice enough. Given that, 2k-3k I think, would be a good estimate...
.