Worthy of a PSA Review? What do you guys think?

[cmfxa]

Hi everyone!

New to the forum and wanted to start off by introducing myself. My name's Colin and I'm a long time reader who's finally decided to register and start posting.
I absolutely love the forum and I found it to be the best resource when I was first learning about T206. There is so much information on here it's absolutely nuts, and I need to thank you guys for the great stuff you do for people getting into the hobby.

I come to the forum today to get an opinion on my T206 Jimmy Collins. It is a recent pickup of mine that I've been considering sending in for a PSA review since in hand, I think the card looks especially nice, even for an 8.
It's super clean with pretty nice centering (about 45/55 Left-Right, and the same Top-Bottom if measuring from bottom of the name), corners and an excellent surface. It also has a low cert number which makes me think half grades weren't being used when it was first graded.
Right now, it's pop 11 none higher, so getting the bump to 8.5 would be super exciting and the thought has clouded my head when it comes to being objective about the card


Here's the gallery of photos, note that most of the tiny scratches shown in the pictures are actually on the slab:

https://imgur.com/a/co3vazv

T206 Jimmy Collins

Things I've noticed about the card that I think could hurt it:

- Top concern: Slight chipping/compression on lower left edge (picture #8)
- Blue ink registration goes slightly below bottom line on front
- Left to right centering on back (though many 9-10s have poor back centering)
- Tiny tobacco stains on back
- Bottom 2 corners look slightly better than upper 2


It would cost about $200 to have it reviewed by PSA (super express). Anyone think it could make the cut? Any opinions or questions are much appreciated! Glad to be part of the forum!

- Colin

[swarmee]

So, the card has a very old cert number (6M) in a new lighthouse slab, so it likely was reviewed in the past year.

But between the blue registration issue and the top left corner, you're not getting higher than an 8. Leave it the way it is.

How are you measuring Top/Bottom centering? To the picture frame or to the bottom of the text? Is that how PSA measures it, or are you guessing?

[cmfxa]

Originally Posted by swarmee

So, the card has a very old cert number (6M) in a new lighthouse slab, so it likely was reviewed in the past year.

But between the blue registration issue and the top left corner, you're not getting higher than an 8. Leave it the way it is.

How are you measuring Top/Bottom centering? To the picture frame or to the bottom of the text? Is that how PSA measures it, or are you guessing?

Yeah I know it's been reholdered recently, just not sure if it was sent in for a review.

Using a scan I measured the number of pixels from the frame to the edge of the card on the sides. If I measure from the bottom of the text, it's about the same as the sides, 45/55.

Appreciate you taking a look!

[MattyC]

PSA will take your fee and probably not even look at the card. Sadly there is a ton of politics in grading these days; they want to send the message that they are tough— and rejecting even worthy cards en masse conveys that message.

[wazoo]

That is an 8.

[Throttlesteer]

Originally Posted by wazoo

That is an 8.

Agreed. PSA 8s are on par with early PSA 9s now. You would have a VERY tough time getting your Collins bumped.