M116 Envelopes/Folders and PSA Grading issue

[caramelcard]

Got a message today on ebay from a "big dealer" stating that my M116 folders/envelopes graded by PSA are not legit. Or, I guess he was stating that the holders were fake. When I got home I looked at the holders and both have a cert number of 12345678 which certainly does seem strange.

I couldn't fathom why someone would actually fabricate oversize holders and place perfectly authentic envelopes in them with no number grade. Doesn't sound like a big money making scheme, but this person is adamant that they're not legit.

I contacted PSA, but the representative didn't know so he's getting back to me at a later time.

Any thoughts?

Here they are:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/M116-Sportin...item19fc4e5755

http://www.ebay.com/itm/M116-Sportin...item1c4eb9cbf8

Thanks all.

Rob

[sb1]

Good as gold, whoever told you otherwise is certainly not familiar with them. I cracked a bunch of these out and they may have also had the same generic 12345678 number.

[4815162342]

Did his eBay message end with "...but I'll take 'em off your hands for half price."?

[caramelcard]

Nope. Just several messages stating that these listings are fishy and that I'm "duping people."

He thinks they're the exact same items because they have the same cert number. I don't have an explanation for that because I don't work at PSA, but I tried to explain that they're real.

He claims there's no way PSA would certify these and that I must've been duped myself when I purchased them.

I bought them separately (one in Goodwin).

Anyways, just sucks to be accused of selling fakes by someone for no reason.

Rob

[milkit1]

That is cool to know PSA will slab them as I have two myself

[Rob D.]

Originally Posted by caramelcard

Nope. Just several messages stating that these listings are fishy and that I'm "duping people."

Here's hoping the board member will identify himself.

[gabrinus]

Don't hold your breath.....