Piedmont Tobacco Print - UPDATE

[John V]

This framed print/poster measures about 21" by 15". Printed in the bottom left corner is Copyright 1908. Can anyone help me on the value of these?
Thanks, John

[3-2-count]

Hi John,
I've been purchasing similar pieces lately in the range of $325 to $375 bucks, leaning towards the higher side if the print is in it's original frame.

[1880nonsports]

retail I'd say 450. - 550. and you take it from there. There are quite a few different ones for the major ATC names relating to brands associated with insert cards - I can think of 6/7 different for the Piedmont brand - in addition to the 2/3 I have. Thematically they appear more "serious" or mature than those of Sweet Caporal - another equally popular brand. As for finding one in the original frame - especially if it has attribution in it - or is particularly ornate - I might pay up to a 25% premium. I have quite a few card related advertising pieces to provide ancillary support for my card collection. The problems begin when one is a completist - these things take up a bit more space than a card :-)

[John V]

To my untrained eye, this appears to be authentic. Are these known to have reproductions floating about?

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by 1880nonsports

retail I'd say 450. - 550. and you take it from there. There are quite a few different ones for the major ATC names relating to brands associated with insert cards - I can think of 6/7 different for the Piedmont brand - in addition to the 2/3 I have. Thematically they appear more "serious" or mature than those of Sweet Caporal - another equally popular brand. As for finding one in the original frame - especially if it has attribution in it - or is particularly ornate - I might pay up to a 25% premium. I have quite a few card related advertising pieces to provide ancillary support for my card collection. The problems begin when one is a completist - these things take up a bit more space than a card :-)

I must be one heck of a bargain shopper, because I've not paid $450/$550 (retail) for any of my similar displays. These are not hard to find and come up for sale quite often. One just needs to be patient and not over pay.

[Bridwell]

That's a really nice one. I could see it selling for over $400.

[1880nonsports]

patience is often rewarded and I appreciate that you are a prudent buyer. There are always good buys in any collectible environment - best equation the motivated seller and responsive buyer. I stand by what I said for any number of reasons not the least of which is that I have quite a bit of experience with the subject. I can expand on my valuation if you really want me too - but it's boring. That being said I encourage discussion and accept others might see things differently than I do. I'd love to see pictures of your tobacco posters as I'm all about tobacco and old enough that I won't get to see it all - but young enough to hope I can get close.......... BTW - presumably you didn't set out to buy a specific piece - and I'm sure you felt you were paying under retail when you negotiated the final price of what you liked. Impulse buys are often more expensive and more likely to be at or above retail - all things being even - so a retail valuation @ 35% above the prices you quoted doesn't seem so far-fetched.