authentic or graded 1 ?

[g_vezina_c55]

i have several time this discution with collector.

What do you prefer, a authentic graded card with a beautifull eyes appeal, but trimmed or altered OR a bad loooking psa 1 card ?


for my part i prefer a untouched card in psa 1 grade....

and you?

[glchen]

I think I would prefer the authentic card rather than the poor PSA 1. However, I'd always be looking to upgrade that card to at least a PSA 1 with decent eye appeal. (e.g. some scrapbook residue on back, pinhole, etc.)

[Vegas-guy]

For some reason I can't bring myself to even consider an "A" graded card. Know matter how nice! I'd take the 1, not sure why other than a better feeling of no one tampering with it???

[bcbgcbrcb]

I believe that most collectors will SAY they prefer an Authentic card with great eye appeal but, in the end, they will choose the "1" grade due to the greater monetary value that it holds.

[kmac32]

Authentic card. Poor cards that look mangled have no appeal to me!

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by Vegas-guy

For some reason I can't bring myself to even consider an "A" graded card. Know matter how nice! I'd take the 1...

+1

[atx840]

I love me some beaters but a clean authentic card would trump a 1. I like the card not the flip.

Plus scraps are always an A

[g_vezina_c55]

for the value, the resell price, the 1 will command a higher price than a AUTH card.

i always prefer original things....


it is like in my past hobby : muscle car

i prefer to own a unrestored untouched muscle car with dings, scratch and not perfect interior or paint instead of a show poodle trailer queen car...

i apply the same rule in the sport card hobby.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by g_vezina_c55

i have several time this discution with collector.

What do you prefer, a authentic graded card with a beautifull eyes appeal, but trimmed or altered OR a bad loooking psa 1 card ?


for my part i prefer a untouched card in psa 1 grade....

and you?

Good question, but it's like asking if I would prefer to listen to Journey or Foreigner. But if I had to choose, it would definitely be an altered card - who wants a "bad-looking" card?

If the choice were a PSA 1 with good eye appeal, or an altered/trimmed card, I would take the PSA 1 any day.

[t206blogcom]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Good question, but it's like asking if I would prefer to listen to Journey or Foreigner.

LOL - good one.

While I have both, I'd prefer 1's over authentics because I like things to be original and unaltered.

[Leon]

I am like a few other posters in that it depends on the 1. If the 1 is super trashed then I would take the AUT. IF the 1 is decent at all then I would take it. All things being equal I prefer not to have altered cards, but do own a few....(I think). regards

oh yeah, my Matty proof and Mullaney overprint are both AUT's....I am sure I have some more too.

[benchod]

Originally Posted by Leon

I am like a few other posters in that it depends on the 1. If the 1 is super trashed then I would take the AUT. IF the 1 is decent at all then I would take it. All things being equal I prefer not to have altered cards, but do own a few....(I think). regards

oh yeah, my Matty proof and Mullaney overprint are both AUT's....I am sure I have some more too.

I agree with Leon; not all 1's or A's are equal
Some A's will sell for much more than a 1 e.g. hand cut Plank Piedmont in REA

[E93]

Originally Posted by benchod

I agree with Leon; not all 1's or A's are equal
Some A's will sell for much more than a 1 e.g. hand cut Plank Piedmont in REA

+1

For me it also depends on the issue too. For example, a skinned N172 with a great image does not bother me too much - a little, but not too much.
JimB

[g_vezina_c55]

Originally Posted by benchod

I agree with Leon; not all 1's or A's are equal
Some A's will sell for much more than a 1 e.g. hand cut Plank Piedmont in REA

If you come across à piedmont plank graded 1 in verry bad shape it will command higher price than the auth you talk.

I know it have no plank graded 1 but it is hypothetic.

You can apply this rules to Sweet cap plank. Wathever the eyes appeal the graded 1 plank will sell for more than auth card

[pcoz]

Apples to apples I'd always take a 1. But, with these two, if the A has this much better eye appeal, to me it's a no-brainer. Also, it depends what is the reason for the A grade. In this case, there is some black notebook paper stuck to the back which accounts for the A.

[tbob]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Good question, but it's like asking if I would prefer to listen to Journey or Foreigner. But if I had to choose, it would definitely be an altered card - who wants a "bad-looking" card?

If the choice were a PSA 1 with good eye appeal, or an altered/trimmed card, I would take the PSA 1 any day.

+1