T206 Pricing Question...

[AK11]

Hi. I am asking the T206 experts here on a general price range on a T206 card I just got graded. It is a T206 Bill Dahlen Brooklyn with a Piedmont 350 back. It was just slabbed by BVG a 4.5. Since the PSA SMR guide is a little off on graded T206 sometimes, what's the possible sell price on a card like this? Under the PSA pop report for Piedmont backs, only 4 5s and 4 6s even exist with most grading a 4. So does my 4.5 give it an edge? I might post it for sale here, but since I do not see Brooklyn Dahlen's graded this well too often, I wanted to ask. Any info is greatly appreciated. Thank you,

Andrew

[Mikehealer]

Hi Andrew
A scan would be nice but, I would guess somewhere between $375-$500 depending on eye appeal.

[AK11]

It will arrive tomorrow from BGS, so no scan yet. It was in a PSA 4 holder when I bought it for $585. I graded it through BVG because I was going to hold onto it, but instead need to sell it. I do realize most prefer PSA/SGC graded vintage, but it is well-protected in a BVG holder and must have been under-graded by PSA. I can post a scan when it arrives if that helps.

[Mikehealer]

Well Andrew, I probably guessed a little low.

[Bosox Blair]

Hi Andrew,

I hate to rain on your parade, but you paid a very high price for your card. Before you bought your PSA 4, VCP shows 18 sales of that card in PSA 4 between $180-$285. None even close to what you paid. In fact, no PSA 5 was even recorded as being sold for more than $515 (and several under $500).

Cheers,
Blair

[AK11]

No parade here. I won in standard auction format so it was bid up to that price. I did not buy it with a outrageous best offer so the price was determined by bids. Of course the auction must have been an anomaly. No big deal as I will probably sell the same way. Thanks for the pricing info.