Carl Horner photo- ID help

[Leon]

I picked up this Horner photo on ebay recently and discovered it's probably not Larry Mclean. I am wondering if it could be "John" Mclean? I heisted a couple of pics from ebay to help. I already have a deal with the seller for a return if it's not at least "one" of the Mcleans . Any and all help is appreciated!!

[jthorn]

It's a catcher ... not McLean but Chief Meyers, I believe.

john thorn

[Leon]

There is a resemblence to Chief Meyers, no doubt. This Horner photo could be an early picture of him but all of the pictures I have seen of Chief Meyers have his left eyebrow as being somewhat "up" on the outside part of it, like he was cut there and got stitches, or something?

[slidekellyslide]

Hey, John Thorn posts here? Who knew?

As for the photo, I saw it on ebay and tried to compare it to McLean, but just wasn't sure. It's definitely not Chief Meyers.

[jthorn]

Gentle men of good will may disagree, of course. But I will stick to my identification of our chap as Meyers, and offer a portrait from 1910 by Paul Thompson as "evidence."

john thorn

[bmarlowe1]

It's neither of the McLean's (clearly) , nor is it Chief Meyers (whom it at least does resemble) - the ears do not match (nor do several other features).

I'll post photos later.

Leon - why didn't you ask me first?