exec and ump hof chances

[theshleps]

Going through my autographs. Only collect HOF
Does anyone think any of these folks have a chance?
George Barr
Buzzy Bavasi
San Breadon
Bing Devine
Charles Ebbets
Charles Finley
Roland Hemond
August Hermann
Bob Howsam
Marge Scott
Arthur Soden
George Steinbrenner
Ted Turner
Dan Topping
as well as the following players
Newt Allen
Ken Boyer
Chet Brewer
Johnny Kling
Marty Marion
Billy Martin
Thurman Munson
Vada Pinson
Allie Reynolds
Quincy Trouppe
Bucky Walters
Maury Wills
Joe Wood

[Flintboy]

Finley and Steinbrenner I think at some point get in.

Lots of talk lately about Pinson getting in, I looked up his stats, impressive career but to me not HOF worthy.

[oldjudge]

Billy and George need to go in together 😂

[BioCRN]

You can probably go ahead and cross Marge Schott off that list.

There's no particular reason as much as there's an argument over which reasons make the Top 10 list and which are better left ranked lower in a Top 20 list.

[Topnotchsy]

I don't think there's any way to know whether the Negro Leagues will add 1-2 players in the next 20 years, or add 10-20 players. Even if it is the latter, it is not obvious who those players will be. The names you mention (Brewer, Allen and Trouppe) are all possibilities, but there are so many players whose stories are being uncovered that there's no way to know. Donaldson, Redding, Malarcher, Vic Harris, Gus Greenlee, Dizzy Dismukes etc. So many names that have a legit shot if the voters (and those who decide what will be voted on) decide to view the Negro Leagues as a parallel league and assume there should be a similar number of inductees. (FWIW, this doesn't seem to have happened.)

[BillyCoxDodgers3B]

We know how this will likely play out. None of those you listed get in, and instead they find the front office equivalent of Harold Baines; a name so obscure that nobody has thought of him in years. Let's have a warm Cooperstown welcome for Marvin Milkes!

As to your list, here's who I'd have no problem seeing enshrined, or in some cases, where logic would outweigh personal preference:

Buzzy Bavasi
San Breadon
Charles Finley
August Hermann
George Steinbrenner

Billy Martin
Joe Wood

I'll defer to others for Negro League players. Never was my area of interest.