PWCC / Jeter Autographics - What the hell is going on?!?!

[VintageGamerN00b]

In 2013, I sent a 2000 Skybox Autographics Purple Foil #d 7/50 into BGS. It came back a 7.5. There were definitely some corners and edges issues (especially the bottom left) but I thought it would come back an 8. I sold it on eBay auction no reserve for $455 late last year.

Suddenly, last month that same card pops up on PWCC's eBay auction as a PSA Gem Mint 10 for $2247? Can someone explain how in God's name this might have happened? Occam's razor says that someone broke it out of the BGS holder, altered it and sent it into PSA and PSA would have to change the grade of 10 to an Authentic or Altered if they knew about this. Do you guys agree with this line of thinking?

[WillBBC]

That is really strange. The truth is out there. Now to find out what Mulder and Scully are up to.

[VintageGamerN00b]

I posted this on Blowout Cards and the guys over there agree that it looks like the card was shaved. I alerted Brent at PWCC and assume that he'll reverse the sale. Stuff like this gets me SO heated.

[7nohitter]

Wow, this is very interesting...I wonder who submitted it for the new grade....keep us posted about what PWCC does!

[Hammerin'Hank]

Any possibility of Skybox making a boo-boo ?

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by Hammerin'Hank

Any possibility of Skybox making a boo-boo ?

That is what I originally thought, but an auto would have not ended up exactly the same in the spot on two cards.

[Ksquared]

Originally Posted by Hammerin'Hank

Any possibility of Skybox making a boo-boo ?

The two autographs do look exactly the same. But, when I look at the two scans, it looks like the 0 and the '/' in the numbering at the bottom right of the card extend closer to the border in the BGS card compared to the PSA card. If that's the case someone couldn't have trimmed the PSA card, right? I'm not familiar with this card but haven't there been others where people posted the same #'d card out of a supposedly limited population card?