Trivia - Name this Rookie Card

[Gr8Beldini]

Because of various reasons, this is one of the quirkier postwar Topps cards. A four player rookie card featuring...

• Player 1 didn't appear on another Topps card until 4 years later.
• Player 2 was appearing on his 2nd Topps card, having appeared on a solo card 4 years earlier.
• Player 3 appeared on a Topps card the following year, then not again until 5 years later.
• Player 4 is the most unusual of the four. I won't tell you what was so unique about the 5 Topps cards he appeared on (it would make this question too easy), but there is enough here to make this question gettable.

Name the card; the 4 players; and the unusual thing about player 4's cards.

[frankh8147]

No idea but ill sort-of attempt to be the first guess because I like this thread so much...the topps card with 4 Yankee Managers on it? Believe is was late 50's, early 60's?

[frankh8147]

1960 Topps #465 I mean..doesn't make my answer right but I consider it to be a semi-educated guess.

[Gr8Beldini]

No, this is an actual Topps Rookie Stars card. Thank you for playing along.

[cardinalcollector]

1965 Topps Indians Rookies #546

1. Mike Hedlund
2. Ray Barker
3. Floyd Weaver
4. Bill Davis (5 Rookie stars cards in a row 1965-1969)

[Gr8Beldini]

That is absolutely correct.