Our friend the crease.

[atx840]

I recently came across this O'Hara as a MakeAnOffer and and it's been stuck in my mind how badly that crease killed the value on a gorgeous card.



I'd love to see your examples of cards you could not have afforded without that grade killing crease/pl/rip

[docpatlv]

Chris,

I know it's a Polar Bear, but I think the tobacco stains bother me more from an esthetic standpoint. The crease that doesn't break the paper is fine by me and the one that does break paper isn't too bad.

[ullmandds]

this crease is much much worse to me!!!!

[docpatlv]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

this crease is much much worse to me!!!!

Put some whiskers on the side and you have yourself a catfish!

[ullmandds]

that crawford is a crying shame!!!!! great card though!!!!!

[oldjudge]

Instead of having an innie or outie belly button, she has a " it would take a bloody Welsh miner to find itie".

[Leon]

It's not a crease but a tiny paper pull, and this card was just shown, but I think it would have been 3-4 grades higher without that little pull on his sleeve. What a shame...

[Ease]

Originally Posted by Leon

It's not a crease but a tiny paper pull, and this card was just shown, but I think it would have been 3-4 grades higher without that little pull on his sleeve. What a shame...

Those are the type of cards I really love, gems with little flaws encased in slabs. With my budget, that's the only way for me to acquire really good looking cardboard.

[DerekMichael]

Oh My Lord. This card looks perfect ... to Hell with the grade!

Originally Posted by Leon

It's not a crease but a tiny paper pull, and this card was just shown, but I think it would have been 3-4 grades higher without that little pull on his sleeve. What a shame...

[mrvster]

but I don't mind so much on any scrap

[RGold]

John, once again, great, great cards.
My only card with a crease(that I know about). .

[conor912]

Originally Posted by docpatlv

Chris,

I know it's a Polar Bear, but I think the tobacco stains bother me more from an esthetic standpoint. The crease that doesn't break the paper is fine by me and the one that does break paper isn't too bad.

I agree. The creases kills it way less for me than the 100 brown dots all over it do.....

[SetBuilder]

Can those tobacco stains soak off?

[christopher.herman]

Recently picked this one up from a fellow member.
The spider creases are virtually invisible... even with a loupe.

[SetBuilder]

Look at this McIntyre. Sharp corners, no paper loss, staining, etc. The only negative is a tiny hairline crease along the side, less than an inch, and only visible if you really look for it. I'm wondering why PSA didn't give the card a few +1's for having perfect centering and corners and instead gave it a lowly 2?! I've seen some really bad looking 2's.

[packs]

I've shown this one before but its still a heart breaker:

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

Originally Posted by SetBuilder

Look at this McIntyre. Sharp corners, no paper loss, staining, etc. The only negative is a tiny hairline crease along the side, less than an inch, and only visible if you really look for it. I'm wondering why PSA didn't give the card a few +1's for having perfect centering and corners and instead gave it a lowly 2?! I've seen some really bad looking 2's.

I would be resubmiting that card.

[atx840]

If there wasn't the crease I'd think this would be a 30-50k card. Thoughts.

[atx840]

What would it likely grade without the crease, 6/7?

PSA 5 sold in REA for 22k

Link

[ullmandds]

So you really mean creases? If all the creases were gone then i may agree?

[Sean]

Originally Posted by atx840

I recently came across this O'Hara as a MakeAnOffer and and it's been stuck in my mind how badly that crease killed the value on a gorgeous card.



I'd love to see your examples of cards you could not have afforded without that grade killing crease/pl/rip

Chris, I'm not going to post it again, but I'm sure the cost of my Plank would have nearly doubled without the creases.

[wonkaticket]

Ahhh the wrinkle the scourge of 30 something women and card collectors….add in a dinged corner or the microscopic spot of paper loss and alas you have the perfect recipe for bumsville.

[atx840]

Excellent cards everyone. Keep them coming.

[t206hound]

When this came back a 60, I didn't believe it... and couldn't sell it for 60 prices. So I held it and sent it in again. Came back a 60. Don't know what I'm missing:

[wazoo]

Originally Posted by t206hound

When this came back a 60, I didn't believe it... and couldn't sell it for 60 prices. So I held it and sent it in again. Came back a 60. Don't know what I'm missing:

Erick, I'm no pro grader, but I think that card deserves at least a 6! It looks like a 7+ to be honest!

[Sean]

Erick. I don't get it either.

[Texxxx]

Eric, I figure it might be the centering on the back. By there grading scale a 80 should have a 75/25 centering on front and allowed a 10% latitude on the back.
I would have given it a higher grade though.

[yanksfan09]

Originally Posted by t206hound

When this came back a 60, I didn't believe it... and couldn't sell it for 60 prices. So I held it and sent it in again. Came back a 60. Don't know what I'm missing:

Did you send it back in the SGC holder or did you crack it out first? I always wondered if companies were influenced by that. If you send in an encased card, maybe they see what they already graded it and are reluctant to bump it much higher as it's a bit of an indictment on their previous work. I don't know.

Same for crossing to another company; if PSA sees a SGC card graded a 5 then would they want to grad it higher? Maybe they feel that will make them seem to have less stringent standards? I would hope that it should not have influence on graders whether or not a card is raw, but I can definitely see how it might. Even if it's on an unconscious level to the grader that day... When you send in a card raw, you're likely getting a fresh slate and a completely honest and unbiased review.

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by yanksfan09

Did you send it back in the SGC holder or did you crack it out first? I always wondered if companies were influenced by that. If you send in an encased card, maybe they see what they already graded it and are reluctant to bump it much higher as it's a bit of an indictment on their previous work. I don't know.

I cracked it and submitted it raw... there's something there that I'm not seeing for it to get the same (relatively low) grade twice.

[teetwoohsix]

Originally Posted by t206hound

I cracked it and submitted it raw... there's something there that I'm not seeing for it to get the same (relatively low) grade twice.

It surely looks better than the grade given (both times).

I would like this card alot better if it didn't have the forehead crease:

Sincerely, Clayton

[aquarius31]

Great thread!