Set Registry

[Archive]

Posted By: Anson

Now PSA, SGC, and GAI have registries. I happen to like GAI's idea the best, in that you can still register PSA or SGC cards. SGC and PSA force you to have your items graded by their own graders. While they might think it encourages more crossovers, it does prevent folks from wanting to participate. If you have an SGC card with a print mark, you wouldn't want to crossover to PSA and get qualifier tagged. Additionally, not that it's a huge deal, but you would lose the "first graded" tag to move over to one of the others.

While the registry isn't for everyone, it has sparked more interest in the hobby. I just wish that the big three would make it a little more user friendly.

[Archive]

Posted By: will watson

"SGC and PSA force you to have your items graded by their own graders."

....on their own website. you say that like PSA and SGC are in the wrong here. if i ran a grading company, i wouldn't want people to register competitors cards on my website either. not to mention, GAI doesn't have the PSA and SGC cert. # databases, so there's no way to tell whether people actually own the cards or not. what's to stop me from going to Marshall Fogels 52 T set, and lifting his serial numbers and registering them as my own on GAI's site?

[Archive]

Posted By: Anson

The registries are for the individual collectors anyway. At least that's what I believe in most cases. You can lift reg #'s from Ebay auctions or internet pics.

In most cases, these cards are already graded. I don't think too many people would want to register a complete set of PSA cards on GAI. But, you might have a few that aren't of one grading company. So now you have to spend the money to have them regraded, just to have them added?

[Archive]

Posted By: WP

Anson,
Do you really think that the GAI first graded label carries the slightest bit of significance?

[Archive]

Posted By: Anson

To me, not at all. But, you do see a lot of folks that are quite proud of it. I guess they don't realize that there are very few GAI "1st graded" examples where PSA and SGC haven't had several slabbed.

Maybe there should be a third-party registry where grading companies didn't play a factor in things.

[Archive]

Posted By: BCDaniels

for VAM dollars Anson!

Will you join us?

[Archive]

Posted By: Frank Evanov

Agree with Will that GAI's concept is pretty much an admission of the lack of high grade GAI-only sets. At present, there are only a dozen baseball collections listed and the majority of them are under 5% completion. Hardly a strong selling point for GAI. Additionally, most of the cards listed are graded by PSA. Advertisement for your competiton is certainly a marketing no-no.

Frank

[Archive]

Posted By: Anson

That's the sad part, It's a marketing no-no. One more example of how the hobby has nearly become extinguished and has become completely business.

[Archive]

Posted By: JimCrandell

I gave permission to Steve Rocchi to put a few of my PSA sets on the GAI registry and nit looks like there are 3 or 4 up there. My understanding was he was going to ask Don, Charlie and Marshall to put certain of there psa sets on the GAI registry.

Dav

[Archive]

Posted By: Wesley

I am not an expert on copyright infringement but did SGC or PSA authorize this use of their work. SGC and PSA probably both enjoy the free advertising for their products, but down the road, can SGC or PSA ask GAI to remove information from a GAI website or to stop engaging in using their work?

[Archive]

Posted By: BCDaniels

I think I will Register it just for fun~. Wes,why would anyone who colleects cards have the slightest concern over grading services copyright laws? Why would any collector care about their legal issues!

[Archive]

Posted By: Wesley

You and I would not care at all Brian. But companies that invest a lot of money to build up their brand names and sell their products might care about these things. Again, I know nothing about IP.....just wondering whether it could happen.

[Archive]

Posted By: davidcycleback

Wesley, your point is legitimate. However, I think PSA might like it if top rated sets in the GAI registry were PSA. Or, at least, they, and the folks at the CU board, would be amused.

[Archive]

Posted By: BCDaniels

promotes the other. if you own a check cashing business you want it right next door to another one! That is how you incur more business. It's good for all of them~