Vintage Trade Thread

[Leon]

We haven't tried a vintage trade thread in a while, so why not?

If even one trade is made, it's a win. If none are made, at least we tried .

I have this very nice T206 Matty up for trade. Prefer a type card I don't have.
thanks and good luck!

Update- this card is in the Brockelman Auction currently..

[B O'Brien]

Update down below in new post

I’m in for some trading! I need to get a couple more duplicates up on the BST.

Need list VG or VGEX:

Cobb Bat On
Crawford throwing

Thanks for starting us off Leon!

Bob

[jingram058]

It's a great idea, and I have made a few great trades on this forum, but I only dabble in raw, ungraded, unslabbed cards.

[ClementeFanOh]

GREAT idea for revival, Leon!

Trent King

[StraightRaceCards]

Have a few T206 cards for trade.

If there are bigger cards involved, I would possibly consider trading a T206 Matty portrait SGC1 and a few others.

Would be interested in: T206 HOF portraits, 1956 Topps HOF, E227 Track or M116 HOF in blue background.

Specific cards I am looking for:
M116 Eddie Collins Blue Background
M116 Mathewson Blue Background
T206 Walter Johnson Portrait
T206 Mathewson Dark Cap polar bear back
1956 Topps Koufax, Aaron, Mays, Clemente, Spahn

[bandrus1]

I have a 2.5 Williams rookie I'm interested in trading. I can't get photos to work from phone but can email or text them

[wazoo]

I am looking for t206 rare backs - have plenty to trade as well. Shoot me a PM. Pic for attention

[Exhibitman]

Breaking with the T206 string here, I have these 1950s Brooklyn Dodgers snapshots available

Ernie Harwell:



Billy Cox:



Preacher Roe:



Looking for vintage snaps of Al Rosen, Sandy Koufax, Don Drysdale, Cubs on Catalina Island, FB players Sid Luckman, Benny Friedman, Marshall Goldberg; basketball snaps or team issues from the Lakers, Bill Russell, Wilt Chamberlain, a 1970 Lakers season ticket stub with Jerry West depicted, rock and roll promo photos, some movie star postcards, weight machine cards of the Marx Bros, Bela Lugosi, Boris Karloff, Buster Crabbe (no hat), Exhibit cards of Karloff, Marx Bros, tour souvenir photos of Lugosi, Exhibit circus sideshow 'freaks' cards, oddball vintage Joe Louis items, vintage NASCAR postcards and cards (pre-1980). Probably more but I'm tired of typing.

[pete zouras]

Creased corner and paper loss on back.

Snodgrass has JSA sticker on the back.

Will consider trade for type card I don't have.

[DeanH3]

Updated Want list,

PSA/SGC
1940 Play Ball Ted WIlliams
1941 Play Ball Ted Williams
1948 Leaf Ted Williams
1934 Goudey Gehrig #37
1933 Goudey Babe Ruth #53
1933 Goudey Babe Ruth #149

Trade bait,

[bigfish]

Looking for an e90-1 cy young or t206 cy young portrait.

Pic is not posting .

Sgc 40 Lenox Marquard throwing. Clean front and back.

[sealmark41]

I have ex to near mint 1940's to 1960's raw including HOFers to trade for 1952 Globe printing minor league cards from the following teams: Galveston White Caps, Baltimore Orioles, Columbus Cardinals, Great Falls Electrics, Fargo, Lewiston Broncs, Ponca City Dodgers Miami Beach Flamingos, Oshkosh Giants or Shawnee Hawks.

Or will purchase. Hope to hear from somebody. Also would like to hear from similar collectors.

Thanks a lot,

Sealmark
mkbow2@surewest,net

[GregMitch34]

Seek M101-2 Sporting News supplements, graded or good raw, will trade same or other.

Also looking for all Mays graded cards....

[brunswickreeves]

M101-2 Fred Clarke for other M101-2…

[gunboat82]

Some wants:
Cracker Jack Hooper
Colgan Cobb
41PB/48L Ted Williams
Bond/Old Gold Jackie
V117/W521/W511/PD3 Ruth
34G/F50/W502 Gehrig
F50 Hack Wilson
Helmar/PX7 W. Johnson

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by pete zouras

Creased corner and paper loss on back.

Snodgrass has JSA sticker on the back.

Will consider trade for type card I don't have.

Is the Red Cross available Pete? What kind of type cards are you looking for?
Tx,
Phil

[wazoo]

Let's bump this thread

[wazoo]

Here’s a few

[B O'Brien]

Hey all,

Leon was right about being a great thread, even if only one gets done. Another member and I knocked off a couple of big cards from our lists from this thread, so figured I would bump it back up and put some fresh cards and want list up.

I have some more trade bait available so let me know if you have anything I need!

Looking for:
T213-1 HOFer
BL 460 HOFer
Cobb Bat On SGC VG or VGEX, would love OM back
3 Finger Brown Old Mill SGC VG or VGEX
Piedmont Factory 42 HOFers

Thanks for looking and consideration,
Bob

[BobbyStrawberry]

I have some Old Judges for trade. There is a post about it the bst section:

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=352838

Thanks

[Chris-Counts]

Here's a very sharp-looking Globe card of Gordon Goldsberry that I would be happy to trade for a Globe card in comparable shape of a player from a team I don't have. The blank back is clean. The teams I already have represented in my collection are Stockton, Sacramento, Charleston, Atlanta (album version), Sioux City and Ogden.

[MuncieNolePAZ]

I am making my 1914 CJ Cobb and WaJo potentially available for trade.

I am specifically looking for the following cards.
1923-24 Billiken Pop Lloyd
1924-25 Aguilitas #846 Pop Lloyd
1924-25 Aguilitas #870 Pop Lloyd
1923-24 Billiken Oliver "Ghost" Marcell
1923-24 Tomas Gutierrez Oliver "Ghost" Marcell
T205 Hindu Walter Johnson
T206 Old Mill (Portrait) Walter Johnson
T206 Hindu Red (Hands at Chest) Walter Johnson
T206 Lenox Black (Hands at Chest) Walter Johnson

Cash would be used to make up value difference.

Please PM if you have any of these and are potentially willing to make a deal.

Thanks
Chad

[bbcard1]

Originally Posted by bandrus1

I have a 2.5 Williams rookie I'm interested in trading. I can't get photos to work from phone but can email or text them

I'd be very interested in talking to you.

[Leon]

There are some nice cards in this thread but it's not easy making trades. I am willing to trade anyone, any one of my cards in my collection, for something I want more. Please note, only the top 1/3 are my current collection and the old and new collections are labeled as such. Fortunately, quite a few cards from my old collection made it back into my new one. Thanks for looking.

ps...please don't offer a common card (unless it's a centered '51 Bowman Mantle) for a super rare one, it probably won't work.

https://www.luckeycards.com/personal.html

[Leon]

Originally Posted by pete zouras

Creased corner and paper loss on back.

Snodgrass has JSA sticker on the back.

Will consider trade for type card I don't have.

Glad to hear a few trades have been made because of this thread.

Hey Pete
You still have the Red Cross for trade? Nice cards....
.

[sycks22]

Willing to trade these bad boys. Looking for Wagners and other pre war HOFers

[wazoo]

Some fun ones - looking for rare backs if you can’t tell

[gunboat82]

I'm constantly shuffling cards around in my little baseball corner, where I only have room for about 12-15 at any given time. I'm currently looking for the following (prefer lower grades with decent eye appeal):

• W519 Ruth
• E94 Speaker
• F50/W502 Gehrig
• 1934 Goudey/WWG Gehrig Yellow
• Goudey Ruth 53 or 144
• 1941 Play Ball Williams
• Colgan Cobb or T206 Bat Off Cobb
• 1910 ASG Photo
• 1934 Foxx/Gehrig Photo

[Kevlo17]

Have the following I’d be willing to trade - having trouble uploading pics but can share directly if any interest.

1933 Goudey Ruth’s - 144 SGC 1, 149 SGC 1, and 181 SGC 1.5

1929 Shonen Ruth SGC 2.5

1948-49 Musial PSA 3

Type 1 photos of Hornsby, Dizzy Dean, Ruth, and Gehrig


Looking for the following primarily in lower grade - happy to do partial or all cash deals as well.

1914 CJ HOF

1915 CJ Mathewson

Cobb and Wagner M101-2 (multiplayer and solos)

Cobb Or Matty T3

1933 Gehrig Delong

48-49 leaf jackie

52 topps Jackie


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bocca001]

I'm willing to trade these somewhat rare back Chase cards. I'm mostly looking for a T206 Lajoie portrait. But I'm open to discussing anything interesting (up through the 1980s).

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Kevlo17

Have the following I’d be willing to trade - having trouble uploading pics but can share directly if any interest.

1933 Goudey Ruth’s - 144 SGC 1, 149 SGC 1, and 181 SGC 1.5

1929 Shonen Ruth SGC 2.5

1948-49 Musial PSA 3

Type 1 photos of Hornsby, Dizzy Dean, Ruth, and Gehrig


Looking for the following primarily in lower grade - happy to do partial or all cash deals as well.

1914 CJ HOF

1915 CJ Mathewson

Cobb and Wagner M101-2 (multiplayer and solos)

Cobb Or Matty T3

1933 Gehrig Delong

48-49 leaf jackie

52 topps Jackie


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Pics taken from a phone are usually way too big to upload.

[Kevlo17]

That seems to be my issue, thanks Leon!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[wazoo]

Bumpppppp .... do I need to do some more digging? Plenty more ammo

[pete zouras]

for card of equal value thanks

[DeanH3]

Thought I would bump this thread since I have a few cards on the want list. Have this nice T205 Cobb SGC 2, as well as other cards, to dangle as trade bait.

Ultimate dream want - '33 Goudey Ruth #53 or #149 PSA/SGC 2
Others
'38 Goudey DiMaggio PSA/SGC 2-3 range
'41 Play Ball Williams PSA/SGC 3-5 range
'48 Leaf Ted Williams PSA/SGC 2-4 range
'34 Goudey Gehrig #37 PSA/SC 2-3 range

[RayBShotz]

I would trade this M101-4 Green Joyce Back for equally valued W514 Strip Cards or M101-4 Sporting News Backs.
RayB

[samosa4u]

I'm willing to trade this beauty for another cool vintage baseball card ... maybe a lower-grade Koufax rookie ?? Dunno ... let me know what'cha got ...

[eb28010]

My local card shop, who is very nice, offered a very nice PSA 5 -1952 Bowman Mantle that is well centered and has nice print clarity, plus $6000, for my complete 1968 topps set that has 65 graded cards. Here are a few of the graded players.

psa 9- Gibson, Brock, Maris, Killebrew, Hunter, Cepeda and Flood.
psa 8.5- Drysdale and F. Robinson.
psa 8- Mantle, Aaron, Clemente, Rose, Kaline, Banks, Yastrzemski, Perez, R. Allen, Carlton, Morgan, Mathews, Palmer, Jenkins, Clemente AS, Aaron AS and Stargell.
psa 7.5 Seaver and Bench
psa 7 - Carew
psa 6 -a very nice Ryan.
I'm sure it may be difficult to be completely accurate in your assessment but any opinions on this trade proposal would be much appreciated. Card shop owner is far more experienced trading than I so naturally I think he is getting the better deal. Thanks in advance

[Leon]

I made a nice trade with Val yesterday at the vintage get together. A Holland Creamery for a D381 with tab. Trading is great as long as both parties come to the table with something the other wants.

[jingram058]

Originally Posted by Leon

I made a nice trade with Val yesterday at the vintage get together. A Holland Creamery for a D381 with tab. Trading is great as long as both parties come to the table with something the other wants.

Trading is how I was able to put together a decent quality 1953 Bowman color & b/w complete set. I daresay it wouldn't have happened any other way given the cost.

[jingram058]

Originally Posted by eb28010

My local card shop, who is very nice, offered a very nice PSA 5 -1952 Bowman Mantle that is well centered and has nice print clarity, plus $6000, for my complete 1968 topps set that has 65 graded cards. Here are a few of the graded players.

psa 9- Gibson, Brock, Maris, Killebrew, Hunter, Cepeda and Flood.
psa 8.5- Drysdale and F. Robinson.
psa 8- Mantle, Aaron, Clemente, Rose, Kaline, Banks, Yastrzemski, Perez, R. Allen, Carlton, Morgan, Mathews, Palmer, Jenkins, Clemente AS, Aaron AS and Stargell.
psa 7.5 Seaver and Bench
psa 7 - Carew
psa 6 -a very nice Ryan.
I'm sure it may be difficult to be completely accurate in your assessment but any opinions on this trade proposal would be much appreciated. Card shop owner is far more experienced trading than I so naturally I think he is getting the better deal. Thanks in advance

No way would I trade a complete 68 set plus cash for a single 52 Bowman Mantle card, no matter how perfect it is. Perhaps a 52 Topps, but that's not happening either unless it's low grade. And even then I wouldn't do it, not for 1 card that I personally don't care for.

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by eb28010

My local card shop, who is very nice, offered a very nice PSA 5 -1952 Bowman Mantle that is well centered and has nice print clarity, plus $6000, for my complete 1968 topps set that has 65 graded cards. Here are a few of the graded players.

psa 9- Gibson, Brock, Maris, Killebrew, Hunter, Cepeda and Flood.
psa 8.5- Drysdale and F. Robinson.
psa 8- Mantle, Aaron, Clemente, Rose, Kaline, Banks, Yastrzemski, Perez, R. Allen, Carlton, Morgan, Mathews, Palmer, Jenkins, Clemente AS, Aaron AS and Stargell.
psa 7.5 Seaver and Bench
psa 7 - Carew
psa 6 -a very nice Ryan.
I'm sure it may be difficult to be completely accurate in your assessment but any opinions on this trade proposal would be much appreciated. Card shop owner is far more experienced trading than I so naturally I think he is getting the better deal. Thanks in advance

A quick eBay search shows PSA 5 1952 Bowman Mantles have sold for around $5500 recently so along with $6000 cash, he's offering you around $11,500 in value. I don't know what your 1968 Topps set with the graded cards you have is worth. You would have to do some work to figure that out (if you already haven't). If you think that would be a fair value for it and prefer to have the 1952 Bowman Mantle instead of the 1968 Topps set, make the trade.

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Leon

I made a nice trade with Val yesterday at the vintage get together. A Holland Creamery for a D381 with tab. Trading is great as long as both parties come to the table with something the other wants.

Leon, thanks again for this trade, which gave me a much nicer looking 1925 Holland Creameries card of Sam Rice than I already had in my collection.

Thanks to Joe T. (of Goldin Auctions), I was able to do another trade at Saturday's Net54 vintage collectors get together in which I acquired a much nicer looking T222 Fatima card of WaJo than I already had in my collection.

[PhillyFan1883]

This thread is a great idea, I will go through my cards and see what can be put on the chopping block

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Leon, thanks again for this trade, which gave me a much nicer looking 1925 Holland Creameries card of Sam Rice than I already had in my collection.

Thanks to Joe T. (of Goldin Auctions), I was able to do another trade at Saturday's Net54 vintage collectors get together in which I acquired a much nicer looking T222 Fatima card of WaJo than I already had in my collection.

The T222 Johnson is a classic of the genre, do you have a scan/pic?

[Leon]

Even though I would prefer a sale, the right trade would be ok too....

[MVSNYC]

Cool thread. I would consider trading this Rare Merkle Back Miscut for a SL Hindu (PSA or SGC numerically graded), or possibly another cool printing error.

[ALBB]

Id like to offer my complete 1911 T 201 mecca double folder set up in trade

[Epps]

I'd trade these for other T206 Gandil/Cicotte backs or any other Black Sox cards that anyone may have.

T206 Gandil.jpg

W519-2 Cicotte.jpg

565-1909-1911-t206-white-border-chick-gandil-sgc-fair-15-1.jpg

565-1909-1911-t206-white-border-chick-gandil-sgc-fair-15-2 back.jpg

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

The T222 Johnson is a classic of the genre, do you have a scan/pic?

Peter, I had to take a photo of my new T222 of WaJo, because my Epson scanner has quit working with my Windows 11 PC; a camera doesn't work well with a slabbed card for me. I've had this raw T222 for many years, and over time, the missing upper right corner has bothered me more and more.