Ebay Listing Mis-graded?

[drazz5]

Hi All,

Was looking at this card on ebay and was really confused. I am no grading expert, but those corners look near pristine. Am I crazy for thinking this looks more like a PSA 5 than a 2.5?

P.S., I was thinking about bidding, so put it in the B/S/T forum, but apologies in advance if this belongs in the other forum.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/11526186096...Cclp%3A2047675

[tiger8mush]

Not sure what is on the front surface to the right of his cheek ... paper lift? Also the back is dirty / stained; at the top left appears to be maybe mildew and the top right might be some chipping.

Guessing its easier to see all this with the slab in-hand. Maybe a wrinkle that the scan isn't picking up?

It is certainly priced like it is under-graded

[Bobbycee]

Could be paper loss on front, between his nose & mouth? Hard to tell despite a decent scan. The back is a bit dirty but not penalized for a stain?

Anyways, great card. Over priced for the grade.

[iwantitiwinit]

Im always leery when they post the scan in a way that I can't scroll over the card and see it enlarged.

[drazz5]

Originally Posted by tiger8mush

Not sure what is on the front surface to the right of his cheek ... paper lift? Also the back is dirty / stained; at the top left appears to be maybe mildew and the top right might be some chipping.

Guessing its easier to see all this with the slab in-hand. Maybe a wrinkle that the scan isn't picking up?

It is certainly priced like it is under-graded

Good observations - they must give more credence to that than I would. My price range is typically in the PSA 3 range, and I am not used to seeing corners like that on my cards, so it instantly got my attention.

Definitely agree on the pricing! haha

[drazz5]

Originally Posted by Bobbycee

Could be paper loss on front, between his nose & mouth? Hard to tell despite a decent scan. The back is a bit dirty but not penalized for a stain?

Anyways, great card. Over priced for the grade.

Agreed! I will refrain from putting in my lowball offer for at least a few more days.

[toledo_mudhen]

Originally Posted by iwantitiwinit

Im always leery when they post the scan in a way that I can't scroll over the card and see it enlarged.

Oddly enough - The images that I post on ebay do NOT always do the "enlargement" thingy.

Some will and some wont - I have contacted eBay (to no avail) googled till my fingers became numb and still there doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason for the behavior.

Now - Having said all of that. When I hover over the Doc White card the enlargement thing DOES work for me using Microsoft Edge Browser.