Honus Wagner question on what card to pick up

[mrreality68]

Hi

I have no Honus Wagners.
Not sure if I will get when yet.
Just starting to research it for future planning
But if I do what would be the first card to go after (forgetting the T206 Well out of my league)
What are the Top Wagner Cards out there after the T206? In order would you rate them?

[rats60]

1914 or 1915 Cracker Jack. After the t206 set, the most iconic set with a Wagner card. E95 is my favorite of the caramel cards.

[Casey2296]

14 CJ to match your Jackson, I also like the PC796, E94 & E95.

[bcbgcbrcb]

1. E107 Breisch Williams
2. W600 Sporting Life Cabinet - Type I Monut
3. National Copper Plate
4. E103 Williams Caramel
5. Tip Top Bread

[Exhibitman]

I am partial to the Horner image. I also like the Max Stein PC.

[Rhotchkiss]

Get a portrait card. The t206 wagner is the most famous and iconic ward in the hobby, so get as close as you can. W600; Rose Co PC (a very nice one just sold in Heritage); M116 Blue and Pastel; E90-2 and E104-II (very rare); e103; D322 Tip Top

[oldjudge]

My favorites are the M101-4/5 Wagners, but I really like photographic images and do not like lithographic cards. I think they are also the best buy of any Wagners.

[x2drich2000]

If you're only going to get one, as Ryan said, I'd lean toward a portrait as well. Personally, I like the D322 the most as it is IMO the closest to the T206. Same orientation, same color scheme, just a little large.

[fisherboy7]

E107 Breisch-Williams


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by fisherboy7

E107 Breisch-Williams

Yes, the E107 and W600 Street Clothes are hands down the best Wagner cards after T206. However, those suckers are so rare and expensive that I did not mention them.

[Ricky]

Finding and then affording a Breisch Williams Wagner represents two different tall orders. I like the M101-4 and E95 Wagner’s and you can both find and afford them.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Yes, the E107 and W600 Street Clothes are hands down the best Wagner cards after T206. However, those suckers are so rare and expensive that I did not mention them.

Those are great Cards. and Ryan is right do to the Rarity and the price those would be out of my league.

[ullmandds]

I also like the portrait cards of hans…yet despite this my current honus stable uncludes:

E90-1
E93
E95

[mouschi]

I *loooooove* the e90-2!

[mrreality68]

selection over load.

A lot to think about thinks for those that shared.

I do like the portraits and currently towards them. Not sure which ones but the Rose Post Cards are really nice.

I also saw the 1911 M110 Sporting News Cabinet Card and those have appeal in both the eye appeal and the Rarity.

Please keep making suggestions the more informed the better the decision

Thanks

[Casey2296]

You could also get the 48 Leaf depicting Honus putting a chaw in his mouth, I could never figure out why they would choose this image, I guess that's a portrait of sorts...
_

[puckpaul]

The National Copper Plate and M101-1 Sporting News are the first and best Wagners besides the T206. Both are rare. My favorite issues, with the great portraits and the bio on the back. Would rank those at the top along with the W600s and then the E107.

[trambo]

Budget matters and I’ve always liked the game cards (National Game and Tom Barker) as they don’t tend to break the bank.

[paul]

I think the E-300 is gorgeous. Sorry I don't have a scan of one.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by paul

I think the E-300 is gorgeous. Sorry I don't have a scan of one.

Hi

I just googled the E-300 series amd you are right those are both rare and amazing looking
Out of my league at this point but amazing looking
Put on my bucket /dream list

[pcoz]

You know my favorite Jeff!



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[clydepepper]

Originally Posted by trambo

Budget matters and I’ve always liked the game cards (National Game and Tom Barker) as they don’t tend to break the bank.

or the 1914 Polo grounds Game. The advantage to the playing card issues is that they were made with rounded corners and you can pick one up in great condition for a small amount compared to all the others that have been mentioned (except for the Leaf of him as a coach). I much prefer the picture on the Polo Grounds to the one on the National Game.

1914 Polo Grounds- HONUS WAGNER - BST - 832.jpg

Some folks don't consider the playing cards actual Baseball Cards, but they were produced during Honus's career and that makes it good for me.

[terjung]

Here is another thread about Wagners showing a few more that haven't been mentioned here yet.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=218377

[Bicem]

Terjung sighting!

Hope you're doing well Brian!

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by Bicem

Terjung sighting!

Hope you're doing well Brian!

Ditto that. Hi Brian.....

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by pcoz

You know my favorite Jeff!



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes Pete I know and that is my favorite to.

Just send it to me please

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by terjung

Here is another thread about Wagners showing a few more that haven't been mentioned here yet.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=218377

Great Link to the other Thread

Thanks

[Baseball Rarities]

I have always liked this 1908 PC770 American League Publishing Company postcard which features his classic Horner portrait along with a great batting pose. Nice that it was issued at the height of his career in 1908 - probably his greatest season. It is also very rare. I am only aware of three examples.

[terjung]

Hey, all!

Thanks for posting that ALPC of Wagner, Kev. That my be my favorite since it shows photographic images of a portrait as well as batting. I'm a big fan of B&W photo-based pieces and that one has the best of both worlds!

Good to see you too, Jeff and Tony!

[robertsmithnocure]

I would vote for one of the cards that features the famous Carl Horner portrait, preferably in black and white. It is interesting how some of these portrait cards are orientated to the right while others reversed the negative and show him looking to the left.

[Rhotchkiss]

Here is Horner BW of Wagner. And a batting black white. Two toughies

[brianp-beme]

Here's the E300 Plow's Candy of Wagner. I agree...it is pretty spectacular. And goodness no, this isn't mine.

Brian

[Bicem]

Max Stein postcard has same image, underrated card in my opinion.

That ALPC is also a favorite of mine.

[ccre]

Most definitely E90-2

[mrreality68]

I always knew there were amazing Wagner Cards Out there. But I amazed to learn of some of the rare cards and sets that I never knew existed.
Lot's to think about and I have my eye on one.
If the Deal works out I will share it with the team and of course always on the hunt for more at some point in the future.

[Yoda]

While it isn't a portrait, I have always loved and still covet the E94 Wags with its unique batting pose. Kinda pricey, though.

[puckpaul]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

Here's the E300 Plow's Candy of Wagner. I agree...it is pretty spectacular. And goodness no, this isn't mine.

Brian

That’s a great card!

[mrreality68]

After some reflection and with some member reaching out to me with choices.

This is what I chose for my First Wagner Card for my long term collection

Thanks Jay Cee Mr. "Bean Town" for a great transaction

[BeanTown]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

After some reflection and with some member reaching out to me with choices.

This is what I chose for my First Wagner Card for my long term collection

Thanks Jay Cee Mr. "Bean Town" for a great transaction

Your welcome Jeff and hope you enjoy it for a longtime.

[sb1]

Probably the absolute best choice in my opinion(biased as it may be as I have a Rose PC as well).. I could be wrong as I did not check, that might we one of the nice one/higher graded.

[Baseball Rarities]

Great pickup. Congratulations.

[Rhotchkiss]

awesome f-ing card Jeff. Great decision. A Wagner + a Rose Co = bad ass

[mrreality68]

Thanks everyone for the advise

This forum really did help me both researching and selecting what to get.

This thread led to the transaction.

Now I would love to say I am done with Wagner for a while.

So like all addicts in our collectors realm

WE shall See

[Vintagedeputy]

This will probably be my first, last and only Wagner….and I’m ok with that!

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Vintagedeputy

This will probably be my first, last and only Wagner….and I’m ok with that!

I think it is a beauty and it is worthy of any collection

Congrats

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

After some reflection and with some member reaching out to me with choices.

This is what I chose for my First Wagner Card for my long term collection

Thanks Jay Cee Mr. "Bean Town" for a great transaction

[Carter08]

Really awesome card, congrats. Slight bonus is the SGC label going with Honus instead of Hans. E93 and E98 are the same image but the former is usually labeled Honus and the latter is usually labeled Hans.

(Although I'm a softy for E93, my favorite Honus cards have to be E95 and E90-2.)