Most inaccurately graded PSA 8 of all time?

[marcdelpercio]

Well, okay...maybe there's ONE that's a bit better known, but this one has to at least take the silver medal. I rarely ever post or comment on grading topics, but this one blew my mind. Unless I'm missing something here, this card has:

- A surface wrinkle/crease on the center of the top front edge and bottom right corner of the back

- Multiple spots of surface damage or flecks of paper loss including a 1/4 inch chunk on the top border of the back

- Cut/damage on the lower left edge

- And of course the prominent writing right across the center of the card

Yikes.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1911-M116-S...gAAOSwuMZZCeIM

[swarmee]

Left side of case looks frosted, and there are some cracks on the back of the case. Could be opened and swapped. They don't all seem to have "FielD" written on them either.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Looks like your typical PSA graded card to me.

91 flavors available. Drink up, folks!

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Looks like your typical PSA graded card to me.

91 flavors available. Drink up, folks!

This asset has been conserved, not altered, IMO.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Hard not to be suspicious of a graded card on a white background, though I'm sure I've done it myself occasionally without thinking, it makes it much harder to see case damage.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

This asset has been conserved, not altered, IMO.

If it were mine, I'd resubmit. Looks like a PSA 9 to me.

[prestigecollectibles]

I contacted the seller asking how that card got a PSA 8 and this is his response

Hi,

That's a great question and I don't know the answer. I did not submit the card to PSA myself. The holder appears to me to be in sound condition. I bought it several years ago from a highly reputable seller. I have also seen that this exact same card (with the same PSA i.d. and with the same letters on the uniform) also sold as far back as 2010 (on ebay, on 1/15/10, selling for $449.00), so I assume it was graded by PSA sometime prior to then and has since traded hands at least a couple times.

Best wishes,

[bbnut]

Well it's not for charity, and he didn't say "God bless" so it must be legit, right?😉

[chalupacollects]

From what seller is saying tells me that the original card was cracked out and replaced at least 8 years ago...

[Throttlesteer]

The holder's bottom edge definitely looks suspect. But, the only other reasonable explanation is the grader was sucking back on some of grandpa's ol' cough medicine before grading this one. It might have a shot at a PSA 4.5(mk) in reality land.

[oldjudge]

Wouldn't that be the Wagner?

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

If it were mine, I'd resubmit. Looks like a PSA 9 to me.

David,
I actually think the card has a shot a 10 with the right grader..... All kinding aside, Seller got a great break on this one....Just imagine if it was a T206?

[Leon]

The writing is the big issue for me. How can anyone grading that card miss that?

Originally Posted by marcdelpercio

Well, okay...maybe there's ONE that's a bit better known, but this one has to at least take the silver medal. I rarely ever post or comment on grading topics, but this one blew my mind. Unless I'm missing something here, this card has:

- A surface wrinkle/crease on the center of the top front edge and bottom right corner of the back

- Multiple spots of surface damage or flecks of paper loss including a 1/4 inch chunk on the top border of the back

- Cut/damage on the lower left edge

- And of course the prominent writing right across the center of the card

Yikes.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1911-M116-S...gAAOSwuMZZCeIM

[Peter_Spaeth]

Ultimately it's stupid to sell this card without a full disclaimer because it just makes the seller look bad, IMO.

[glynparson]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Looks like your typical PSA graded card to me.

91 flavors available. Drink up, folks!

And stupidity like this is why you are a laughing stock and probably why I got a plethora of emails from people thanking me for calling you an idiot. It’s clear you have an agenda and despite your self proclaimed expertise have never shown yourself to be anything but a little bitch sitting on your keyboard typing freaking nonesense all the while thinking you are so damn clever. You’re a joke and your continuous signing of the same tune is tiresome you blathering jackass.

[Frank A]

A little hot aren't we. Actually I was sitting at my desk LMAO.