1910 sporting news help

[fduran27]

Not sure if the seller is here, but i have a chance to buy the below. i would rate them as between A to 3 in grades and not sure of what total value you would put as i am not familiar with the set... any help would be appreciated.

Team Name of Player Year
New York Nationals Crandall 1910
New York Nationals Tenney 1910
New York Nationals G. Wiltse 1910
New York Nationals Murray 1910
New York Nationals Bridwell 1910
New York Nationals Raymond 1910
Chicago Nationals Kane 1910
New York Nationals Mathewso 1910
New York Nationals Snodgrass 1910
New York Nationals Merkle 1910
New York Nationals Seymour 1910
New York Nationals L. Doyle 1910
New York Nationals Devlin 1910
Chicago Nationals Overall 1910
New York Nationals McGraw 1910
New York Nationals Schlei 1910
Chicago Nationals Reulbach 1910
Chicago Nationals Beaumont 1910
Chicago Nationals Sheckard 1910
Chicago Nationals Chance 1910
Chicago Nationals Tinker 1910
Chicago Nationals Steinfeldt 1910
Chicago Nationals Kane 1910
Chicago Nationals Kling 1910
Chicago Nationals Evers 1910
Chicago Nationals Hofman 1910
Chicago Nationals Needham 1910
Chicago Nationals M. Brown 1910
Chicago Nationals Schulte 1910
Chicago Nationals Overall 1910
Chicago Nationals Pfiester 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Bates 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Bransfield 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Magee 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Moore 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Moran 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Knabe 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Jacklitsch 1910
Philadelphia Nationals McQuillan 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Moren 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Dooin 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Grant 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Doolan 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Foxen 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Sparks 1910
Philadelphia Nationals Ewing 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Byrne 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Maddox 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Leifield 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Hyatt 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Wilson 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Miller 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Adams 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Clarke 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Leever 1910
Pittsburg Nationals O'Connor 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Hans Wagner 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Gibson 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Leach 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Phillippe 1910
Pittsburg Nationals Camnitz 1910
Washington Americans Unglaub 1910
Washington Americans Elberfeld 1910
Washington Americans Conroy 1910
Washington Americans Johnson 1910
Washington Americans Street 1910
Washington Americans Gessler 1910
Washington Americans Reisling 1910
Washington Americans McAleer 1910
Washington Americans Milan 1910
Washington Americans Schaefer 1910
Philadelphia Americans Krause 1910
Philadelphia Americans E. Collins 1910
Philadelphia Americans H. Davis 1910
Philadelphia Americans Murphy 1910
Philadelphia Americans Dygert 1910
Philadelphia Americans Bender 1910
Philadelphia Americans Plank 1910
Philadelphia Americans Coombs 1910
Philadelphia Americans Oldring 1910
Philadelphia Americans Living Stone 1910
Philadelphia Americans Baker 1910
Philadelphia Americans Barry 1910
Philadelphia Americans Heitmuller 1910
Philadelphia Americans Thomas 1910
Philadelphia Americans Connie Mack 1910
Philadelphia Americans Hartsel 1910
Chicago Americans Dougherty 1910
Chicago Americans Tannehill 1910
Chicago Americans Blackburn 1910
Chicago Americans Hugh Duffy 1910
Chicago Americans Purtell 1910
Chicago Americans White 1910
Chicago Americans Walsh 1910
Chicago Americans N/a 1910
Chicago Americans Parent 1910
Chicago Americans F. Smith 1910
Chicago Americans Hahn 1910
Chicago Americans Sullivan 1910
New York Americans Cree 1910
New York Americans Chase 1910
New York Americans Wolter 1910
New York Americans LaPorte 1910
New York Americans Stallings 1910
Detroit Americans T. Jones 1910
Detroit Americans Beekendorf 1910
Detroit Americans Summers 1910
Detroit Americans Schmidt 1910
Detroit Americans Works 1910
Detroit Americans McIntyre 1910
Detroit Americans Mullin 1910
Detroit Americans O'Leary 1910
Detroit Americans Bush 1910
Detroit Americans Moriarty 1910
Detroit Americans Crawford 1910
Detroit Americans Ty Cobb 1910
Detroit Americans Jennings 1910
Detroit Americans Willett 1910
Detroit Americans W. Donovan 1910
Detroit Americans D. Jones 1910
Cleveland Americans McGuire 1910
Cleveland Americans Niles 1910
Cleveland Americans Berger 1910
Cleveland Americans Flick 1910
Cleveland Americans Turner 1910
Cleveland Americans Clarke 1910
Cleveland Americans Bradley 1910
Cleveland Americans Bemis 1910
Cleveland Americans Stovall 1910
Cleveland Americans Lajoie 1910
Cleveland Americans "Cy" Young 1910
Cleveland Americans Lord 1910
Cleveland Americans Falkenburg 1910
Cleveland Americans Joss 1910
Cleveland Americans Birmingham 1910
St. Louis Americans Hoffman 1910
St. Louis Americans Pelty 1910
St. Louis Americans O'Connor 1910
St. Louis Americans Stone 1910
St. Louis Americans Graham 1910
St. Louis Americans Schweitzer 1910
St. Louis Americans Stephens 1910
St. Louis Americans Waddell 1910
St. Louis Americans Wallace 1910
St. Louis Americans Powell 1910
St. Louis Americans Howell 1910
St. Louis Americans Bailey 1910
St. Louis Americans Hartzell 1910
Boston Americans Karger 1910
Boston Americans Hall 1910
Boston Americans Harry Lord 1910
Boston Americans Donahue 1910
Boston Americans Cicotte 1910
Boston Americans Wagner 1910
Boston Americans Carrigan 1910
Boston Americans Thoney 1910
Boston Americans Stahl 1910
Boston Americans McConnell 1910
Boston Americans Arrelanes 1910
Boston Americans Engle 1910
Boston Americans Herzog 1910

[x2drich2000]

Honestly, in my opinion, no one here can give you a good estimate from just the info provided. A couple of the key cards (Cobb, Wagner, Mathewson, etc) could vary considerable based on condition and variation. Cobb alone for instance, could be as low as $200 in an ugly A (pastel) or $2500+ in an attractive 3 (blue).

DJ

[fduran27]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

Honestly, in my opinion, no one here can give you a good estimate from just the info provided. A couple of the key cards (Cobb, Wagner, Mathewson, etc) could vary considerable based on condition and variation. Cobb alone for instance, could be as low as $200 in an ugly A (pastel) or $2500+ in an attractive 3 (blue).

DJ

What info should I gather? I am trying to get pictures

[timn1]

From the players involved, we are talking about the M116 SPORTING LIFE set, correct?

[fduran27]

Originally Posted by timn1

From the players involved, we are talking about the M116 SPORTING LIFE set, correct?

yes sir!

[fduran27]

I was able to get a few pictures

[brianp-beme]

Just to point out the Lajoie and Cobb on the bottom of the sheet shown are actually T206 cards.

Brian

[fduran27]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

Just to point out the Lajoie and Cobb on the bottom of the sheet shown are actually T206 cards.

Brian

I know sir - those are sold already to someone else

[timn1]

Well, Felipe, they look real from the scans, and the key cards seem to be in decent shape. you can value the Cobb and Wagner at more than 2k each, the cy young and Johnson at maybe 1k. Typical HOFers at 200-400 depending on conditions. Commons run from 20-80 apiece. Good luck.

[fduran27]

Originally Posted by timn1

Well, Felipe, they look real from the scans, and the key cards seem to be in decent shape. you can value the Cobb and Wagner at more than 2k each, the cy young and Johnson at maybe 1k. Typical HOFers at 200-400 depending on conditions. Commons run from 20-80 apiece. Good luck.

Thank you tim

[Leon]

Nice cards. Good luck with them.

Originally Posted by fduran27

I was able to get a few pictures

[fduran27]

Originally Posted by Leon

Nice cards. Good luck with them.

Thanks but the guy wants an unreasonable amount.... made him a reasonable offer but he feels the Cobb and Wagner are 25k each... that should tell you something

[timn1]

Good grief, that's insane.... Cobbs in PSA7 sell for 6-8k. This one is a 3 at best. Whole m116 sets don't go for 25k. Who is this person anyway?

[Jobu]

That's nuts. I'll let you have my blue Cobb for 50% of that:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/132359...7649438320883/

How can you say no to am offer like that - 50% less!! 😁

Originally Posted by fduran27

Thanks but the guy wants an unreasonable amount.... made him a reasonable offer but he feels the Cobb and Wagner are 25k each... that should tell you something

[Leon]

It tells me I should I walk away and say no thanks. If he wants to sell them for a fraction of that then let me know. Otherwise, I would say good luck.

Originally Posted by fduran27

Thanks but the guy wants an unreasonable amount.... made him a reasonable offer but he feels the Cobb and Wagner are 25k each... that should tell you something