ISA Grading company ?

[Ribbens]

Anyone help me ID this ISA Grading company ? Is it defunct legit ? I see this Jackie Robinson card graded by that company and wondering if it is legit. Thanks

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Man I didn't think you could stump me on goofball grading companies. Congrats!

[x2drich2000]

Not new, but if you dig around, not exactly high praises either. Here's an old thread http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=121462 and from CU https://forums.collectors.com/discus...raded-cards/p1

DJ

[lowpopper]

I have successfully graded cards in ISA holders with PSA and SGC.

That does not mean they are all good, but there is light at the end of the tunnel.

Even CSA slabbed legit cards on occasion. I had a 56 Clemente CSA 7 go to an SGC 84 and I even had a 53 Johnny Podres CSA 7 go to a PSA 7.5

I don’t remember the specific cards I had from ISA but I did crack a few out and get the same grade from the other guys. Good luck

[CobbSpikedMe]

8 years ago I saw an ad for ISA grading and it annoyed me so much that I wrote about it on my blog at the time. Here is a link.

They made 4 mistakes in the ad and I couldn't believe they would send the ad to print with these mistakes. Shortly after I posted it I saw another ad, it was the same ad, but with corrections to all 4 issues I had with it. Anyway, I'll never forget ISA grading for this reason. I don't know if they are still in business or not, but I did believe they were genuinely trying to start a reputable grading company. I would trust the cards in their holders are legit. Whether the grades are accurate or not I don't know, you'll have to decide that on your own.

I must admit that even in my blog post, I made a couple mistakes, but I wasn't advertising a new company that's whole business is to examine things for flaws.

[calvindog]

You should presume that if it's in an ISA holder it couldn't get into a PSA or SGC holder, no matter how much the seller lies to the contrary.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by calvindog

You should presume that if it's in an ISA holder it couldn't get into a PSA or SGC holder, no matter how much the seller lies to the contrary.

Really? Not sticking up for ISA, I could care less, know nothing about them. Having said that, I bought an SBC graded T206 years ago for a dirt cheap price, the card was centered and looked great. The card crossed over to an SGC 96 at the National several years ago (Thanks SBassik). The lesson? Buy the freaking card, not the holder....

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Really? Not sticking up for ISA, I could care less, know nothing about them. Having said that, I bought an SBC graded T206 years ago for a dirt cheap price, the card was centered and looked great. The card crossed over to an SGC 96 at the National several years ago (Thanks SBassik). The lesson? Buy the freaking card, not the holder....

SBC was the direct predecessor of SGC. Possibly the first company to grade cards. Not a fly by night knockoff company.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

SBC was the direct predecessor of SGC. Possibly the first company to grade cards. Not a fly by night knockoff company.

Yes they were, but their graded cards are treated like they have the plague....

[CMIZ5290]

Also, having said that, I remember when GAI graded cards were blowing PSA cards out of the water when they first came out...

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Yes they were, but their graded cards are treated like they have the plague....

Well Joe never cared about centering, and may not have been the best at spotting altered cards, but to the best of my knowledge he wasn't knowingly slabbing bad stuff or overgrading.

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by calvindog

You should presume that if it's in an ISA holder it couldn't get into a PSA or SGC holder, no matter how much the seller lies to the contrary.

This sounds like there should be more to this post. Did you have a bad experience, or know folks that did, with ISA? Not saying you're wrong, but this is a pretty all or nothing statement about them.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Also, having said that, I remember when GAI graded cards were blowing PSA cards out of the water when they first came out...

Very early GAI was good. No question. I don't know how it went so far south, although I have a guess.

[murphy8276]

I have successfully cracked an ISA 6 Bird Magic RC to a PSA 7.

It was my only experience with ISA so far.

[toledo_mudhen]

Looks like they have sold the company.


https://www.sportsauthentication.com/


Still using ISA Flips - I have been to their original site in the past as Probstein seems to end up with a fair share of their slabs.

[Yoda]

Is PRO still in the business? Their cards still occasionally seem to pop up.

[Leon]

Lol

Originally Posted by calvindog

you should presume that if it's in an isa holder it couldn't get into a psa or sgc holder, no matter how much the seller lies to the contrary.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by Yoda

Is PRO still in the business? Their cards still occasionally seem to pop up.

I don't think any of the old fly-by-night companies are left. I guess it depends on how you feel about KSA in Canada.

Anyone else see the laughable "Treasure Detectives" on MSNBC where they investigate a Wagner. The only company the guy would use for authentication was ACA. Supposedly because they're the only ones who would let him stay with the card during the grading process. The guy from ACA actually had the balls to appear on the show too!

It's so obviously a fake the participants in the show have to really stretch to create any suspense.