F/S 2 Mantles 1964 and 1962 Topps GRADED

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

All prices are net to me.

All forms of payment accepted.

Timely returns obviously accepted.

1964 Topps Mantle BVG 5 GREAT CENTERING $120





1962 Topps Mantle PSA 5 $40

[mintacular]

No offense, but most vintage cards don't jump up and down i.e. "on the rise" by taking a small snapshot of five recent sales, and you are comparing apples and oranges depending on the tpg, quality of card in that holder, etc. I think you could try and build a case for certain rookie cards in certain grades i.e. '55 clemente with data over several years but saying the 62 mantle switch batter 5 is "on the rise" is probably not accurate, and if it is, not supported by the data you have posted.

In short, I think it's deceptive/ inaccurate advertising to make this claim on these cards

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by mintacular

No offense, but most vintage cards don't jump up and down i.e. "on the rise" by taking a small snapshot of five recent sales, and you are comparing apples and oranges depending on the tpg, quality of card in that holder, etc.

In short, I think it's deceptive/ inaccurate advertising to make this claim based on the data you have provided.

What? All these prices I am showing are the past 5 sales of the exact same card from the exact same company. The 64 and 65 cards have amazing centering. How is that being deceptive. VCP shows all 3 cards trending up.

Does a up arrow on VCp not mean a card is trending?

[mintacular]

Ok, I have not had a vcp subscription for some time, so if they have some stupid "on the rise" arrow like beckett, etc. than so be it. But let's keep this simple based on one of your listings, this one:

1962 Topps Mantle Switch Hitter PSA 5

This card has also been on the rise with the last 5 sales averaging $47.40 VCP.

4/21/17 eBay BIN danielaaronlee $50.00
3/8/17 eBay Best Offer chessdad3 $40.00
2/1/17 eBay probstein123 $56.01
1/21/17 eBay tripleplayvintagestore $41.00
1/18/17 eBay 4_sharp_corners $49.99

According to this data, in January this card sold for $49.99, and one recently sold in April for $50.00. (and of the three in between 2/3 sold for less). So based on your listing, this card is on the rise! One whole penny! Do you see what I am saying? Don't take this personally, I just don't like when misinformation intended or not is used to make a sale!

In fact, if I were to use your logic/math I would have to sadly say this card is in a small decline LOL

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by mintacular

Ok, I have not had a vcp subscription for some time, so if they have some stupid "on the rise" arrow like beckett, etc. than so be it. But let's keep this simple based on one of your listings, this one:

1962 Topps Mantle Switch Hitter PSA 5

This card has also been on the rise with the last 5 sales averaging $47.40 VCP.

4/21/17 eBay BIN danielaaronlee $50.00
3/8/17 eBay Best Offer chessdad3 $40.00
2/1/17 eBay probstein123 $56.01
1/21/17 eBay tripleplayvintagestore $41.00
1/18/17 eBay 4_sharp_corners $49.99

According to this data, in January this card sold for $49.99, and one recently sold in April for $50.00. (and of the three in between 2/3 sold for less). So based on your listing, this card is on the rise! One whole penny! Do you see what I am saying? Don't take this personally, I just don't like when misinformation intended or not is used to make a sale!

The VCP of this card is $42.00. Past 5 sales is $47.50 (rising 10%). Is that not a increase?

If I made 10% on all my investments i'd be happy.

[mintacular]

Okay, you're right. Clearly the Mantle Switch Hitter in a 5 is "on the rise" based on your total flimsy snapshot over a year and anyone with a brain would know that the '62 mantle switch hitter is growing at a 10% clip based on your apples and oranges data (or misunderstanding of vcp #'s)

[quinnsryche]

Stephen, would trade any of the following for the 64 Mantle or the 65 Carlton:
(price after is my trade value, added up to either of your trade values)
Signed Lefty Gomez photo $10
Signed Lefty Gomez program $15
2 Bobby Bragan handwritten Texas Rangers letters $10
2 Super Bowl XXII press pins $25
Signed Jack Morris no-hitter ball $10
Signed 1995 Chicago White Sox team ball $20
2 1956 Topps pins of Dale Long $10
1957 49ers press guide signed by Hugh McElhenny $15
Billyball hardcover book (no dj) signed by Billy Martin $30
6 signed Enos Slaughter cards $30
Signed Stan Musial porcelain card /475 $20
Signed 1959 Topps Stan Musial porcelain card $35

Pick and choose whatever you want, added up to your trade value for either card.
Thanks,
Tony

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by mintacular

Okay, you're right. Clearly the Mantle Switch Hitter in a 5 is "on the rise" based on your total flimsy snapshot over a year and anyone with a brain would know that the '62 mantle switch hitter is growing at a 10% clip based on your apples and oranges data (or misunderstanding of vcp #'s)

What's your problem man. Seems like you don't understand VCP, not me. You don't even have it anymore.

So let's make it simple.

A apple sells for 5 dollars for the past 3 years. Now over the past 6 months to a year it sells for 5.50. Is it not on the rise? What part am I not getting?

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Bumper

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

2 mantles still available. Part of my ultimate trade up. Lowering price of the 1964 to 115 and the 62 to 40

[sycks22]

Can you please calm down on bumping your stuff every 30 seconds? I get the whole trade up thing, but when I check the listings and all of your listing are on the top every day it gets a little old.