Let's See Some Collection "Top Tens"

[MattyC]

So seeing how we are all collectors, I just realized that so many times we are viewing our cards as singular additions (i.e., monthly pickup, auction-specific pickup, or player/set-specific threads).

One aspect of assembling a collection that I've always found satisfying is how the whole can feel so much greater than the parts viewed separately. In other words, it's great seeing a grouping of awesome cards that have become part of one collection-- not unlike a murderer's row-style lineup of great hitters, that lineup becomes its own impressive thing, beyond the hitters examined discretely. Each are impressive on their own, but when you realize a team has all that talent, it takes on a new light.

Anyways, with that in mind, thought it could be cool to see not just the usual one or two, but up to say ten scans of cards from different collections, which would give people a sense of the character or personality of the collection. Could be any cards, for any reason selected to represent a collection.

Of course this would be scan-heavy, but those are my favorite threads-- to me what it's all about. Hence why I love browsing those collection gallery websites now and then.

[brian1961]

This should be an outstanding thread. Showing who you are in 10 cards and what best represents your collection and what is important to you. Give us both barrels, guys! Gnashing my teeth at my own lack of Net tech expertise. ---Brian Powell

[rhettyeakley]

Tried to pick some that I don't show on a regular basis, neat idea for a thread.
-Rhett

[Sean]

I'm afraid that I only collect two sets, but here are a couple of my favorites from these sets:

[DeanH3]

Centering, centering, centering....Did I mention centering?? Unless it's a pretty rare card, centering trumps all for me. I hope you guys don't mind that I keep posting the same cards over and over.

[bcbgcbrcb]

Rhett:

You don't like the rare cards, do you?

Dean:

Great stuff!

[MattyC]

Dean,

Seeing all those centered beauties in one shot is phenomenal. Some real classics there. Much different experience seeing a collection, as opposed to seeing them individually over a long period of time.

I love that horizontal Zeenut up above; what a cool image.

[birdman42]

Pretty clear what my focus is... Here's my top 10.

Bill

[rainier2004]

Nice idea for a thread...

[TheBig6]

[h2oya311]

awesome stuff so far!! Rhett, if you ever want to downgrade your McCarthy Colgan's Chip, let me know...

Here's mine (as of today, in a completely random order):

[t206fix]

Here are my top 10... a few pre-war and a few post-war.

Some are iconic cards of iconic players... some I just love for the pic/player.

[Leon]

The ubiquitous T206s...

[kdixon]

Great thread, some really nice cards.

[T206Collector]

37 Unique Poses...



Dupes with some added "commentary"....






"Poor man's" signed T206s...







Correspondence b/w Fred Snodgrass and renowned T206/Auto collector John D. Wagner, with enclosures...







Mrs. Jane Mathewson and Mrs. Blanche McGraw....

[MBMiller25]

I'm more of a post war guy, so I hope you don't mind.

[MattyC]

Such amazing stuff people have! And so cool to see emerging themes among the cards in a collection.

MBM, you somehow manage to have high-grade cards that still look undergraded! That is my dream Mantle RC right there-- a centered 7 with snow white borders.

The approach I've taken has been like my own spin on the PSA "Top 250 Sportscards" book. Basically choosing cards that I love on an aesthetic level, but when viewed as a whole, they should also form a well-rounded picture of both baseball's legendary players and baseball card history-- all eras. So there is a type-aspect to it, in that I'd want one M101-4/5 card, one CJ, one e90-1, one 52 Topps, etc. Ideally, one day, I'll have all sets and great players represented. Where it is possible to choose, I like centering for eye appeal.

Like many I adore back wear, as it can make a card with a very expensive front affordable. I always love it when a friend or family member will look at a card, then go on to the next one, and not even look at the back!

Chronologically, some key pieces...

[DeanH3]

Thanks Matt and Phil.

There are some AWESOME cards in this thread!!

[g_vezina_c55]

Originally Posted by deanh3

there are some awesome cards in this thread!!

x 2

[Rob D.]

 

[chaddurbin]

Originally Posted by Rob D.

 

nice to see some top shelf lajoies in your collection rob!

[Howe’s Hunter]

Who would be the third baseman photographed with Zach Wheat?

[g_vezina_c55]

Nice Lajoie collection !

[AMBST95]

These are just ten cards that each represent a different subset or area of my collection. They may not be the greatest, but I enjoy them. I hope you do as well.

[kdixon]

Ed, I haven't figured out who the third baseman is . Could have even been before he came to Brooklyn. If anyone else has any idea let me know.

[GasHouseGang]

I like so many different sports and non sports....

[Fred]

Wow, all great stuff. That Snodgrass letter in post 15 is the BOMB! Wow, that is just too cool. Same with the Wheat post card in post 14. Wow!

[25801wv]

Wow - You all have some very nice cards.

[CW]

Damn, great cards, guys!!

I am also a sucker for scan heavy threads, despite my slow connection.

This would be my top 10, removed from their holders with the help of PhotoShop.

[thenextlevel]

Here are my pre-war faves:

[Bestdj777]

Some Yankees and a Westie:

[Mikehealer]

Nothing but Coupons.....

Thanks again for the Bender, Jim.

[wolterse]

no method to my madness

[25801wv]

[xcgrammer]

Originally Posted by 25801wv

I love love love the fact that you included a 89 Upperdeck and a 1990 Leaf Frank Thomas in here. I love pre-war as much as anyone but nothing brings back my childhood like seeing a 1990 Frank Thomas Leaf RC brings me right back to the summer of 1991 when I attempted to trade my entire collection for this card, then went to play baseball at the YMCA after hanging out with my Dad and Grandpa. These moments are what baseball cards are all about. One of the most vivid moments of my childhood takes me right back. Thank you.

[Kawika]

My collection is all over the map: pre-war, post-war, majors, minors, photos, postcards, autographs, artwork etc etc. Hard to pick a definitive "top ten". On any given day each of the following items would qualify as favorites.

Prince Oana









Baltimore at Montreal, 1905


Japanese high school baseball, Koshien Stad, 1936. Love the composition of this rundown.


Recent pickup at Chicago National


Smokey Joe Kreindler

[uffda51]

[t206blogcom]

[bwbc917]

Here are a few from my collection, the Hassan was one of my first vintage finds back in the late 70's. The Rocky HR Derby is my FAV.

[jb217676]

Here's ten from me...

[g_vezina_c55]

Beautifull topps test orr

[jerrys]

n162-anson.jpg

r305-hornsby.jpg

rose-waddell.jpg

scrapps.jpg

[MikeGarcia]

..... the '' Oh , Wow'' aspect of all the previous posts is jaw-dropping..

Just a few

[yanksfan09]

Great cards everyone! I could make this list almost all D381, but to try and break it up: In no order: (accidentally posted 11)

[68Hawk]

Uhh, those are incredibly crisp T213's Mike Healer!!!! Absolutely beautiful

10 I'd hate to have go....

[Hot Springs Bathers]

I never thought I would ever see a "Lethal Leigh" Mathews card posted on this site. I had to chuckle, back in the 80's I would tape the Friday night Aussie rules games on ESPN and watch them later, Mathews was my favorite!

[68Hawk]

"Lethal" Leigh Mathews earned his moniker in many ways.
Considered the greatest player of all time in Aussie rules football, he scored, he dominated, and he was feared because he could put you to sleep. He then went on to coach two different teams to a combined 4 premierships, the super bowls of Aussie Rules.

This youtube tells you all you need to know, and is part of the folklore of my hometown game.




Breaking a wooden goal post by running into it, as Australian as you can get


If you'd like to know if Aussie rules is as tough as is suspected, check the following youtube from the same week of games (circa 1982), specifically the Hawthorn / Essendon game which were notorious for their vigor.

[rainier2004]

I really like this thread, cards all over the place. Im going to add another 10, hope no one minds...

[bcbgcbrcb]

Great idea for a thread, Matt..............