Photo player Identification help

[repsher]

Hi Guys,

I recently picked up a couple of photos and I'm not sure who is the player in each of them.

The first one is dated May 11th 1912. I am thinking it could be Cy Morgan or Chief Bender.
1912athletics001.jpg 1912athletics(back)001.jpg

The 2nd on is dated Oct 9th 1934. Which would be the last game of the WS (Detroit and STL).

ballplayer0012.jpg ballplayer(BACK)0022.jpg


Any help or comments would be appreciated.

Thanks,
Ryan

[thecatspajamas]

Will take another look when I get back to my computer and a bigger screen, but in the meantime keep in mind that the file date, which is the date stamped on the back, is generally a few days after the photo was actually shot. It took a while for the photo to make the rounds before being filed away in the morgue.

With that in mind, is there a reason you doubt whoever wrote Mel Ott on the back of the second photo?

[Dto7]

First photo is at Hilltop Park in New York..most likely taken between April 23-25 1912 when the A's played at New York.

[thecatspajamas]

This is the closest I can come to a shot of Ott from that angle (this one circa 1938), but I don't see any reason to doubt the ID on the back of the photo. I'm assuming you had eliminated him as a possibility based on the date?

[horzverti]

The Philadelphia Athletics player is Claud (Claude) Derrick.

Nice original Bain pick-up Ryan.

[horzverti]

...and your image with ID at top.

[repsher]

Originally Posted by horzverti

...and your image with ID at top.

Wow, that was quick. Thanks for the positive ID. I certainly came to the right place.

[repsher]

Originally Posted by thecatspajamas

This is the closest I can come to a shot of Ott from that angle (this one circa 1938), but I don't see any reason to doubt the ID on the back of the photo. I'm assuming you had eliminated him as a possibility based on the date?

Well that and the fact that the back seems to be scribbled out. Plus, I didn't think it looked much like him. But with the photo you've posted it does look most likely like it his him. Great news since I picked the photo up for around $15.

Thanks.

[thecatspajamas]

Originally Posted by repsher

Well that and the fact that the back seems to be scribbled out. Plus, I didn't think it looked much like him. But with the photo you've posted it does look most likely like it his him. Great news since I picked the photo up for around $15.

Thanks.

The scribbling seems to be done to the entire back of the photo, not just Ott's name, so I don't think it was meant to ex him out as the identified subject of the photo. I'm not sure why the entire back of the photo would be shaded like that, but that's my take on it.

I would do the ear check to confirm, except that I'm awful at it and wouldn't want to mislead. Perhaps if you were to post a larger cropping of just his head though someone else can confirm.