Yum Yum card errors: Tido's and Fido's

[bmarlowe1]

As the year draws to a close, I wanted to thank Leon for hosting a great forum, moderator Dan for his frequent support, and many other board members for their support both on the forum and in emails and for sending me some great images.

Anyway - if these Yum Yum errors are already known to the hobby - then at least I have educated myself:



Happy New Year

[E93]

The same error is present on the Four Base Hits card. It also depicts Billy Sunday, but names Daily.
JimB

[Joe_G.]

Good thread Mark, there are other errors as well by A. Beck & Co. and SGC alike. This is not Lady Baldwin; doesn't look much like Mark "Fido" Baldwin either.



I suspect it is a member of the Chicago team but not sure who. Will start studying the clean-shaven members.

[rhettyeakley]

It is Flynn...

[bmarlowe1]

It's Jocko Flynn: (OK Rhett - you beat me by 1 minute )

[Joe_G.]

Yes indeed, I didn't have a copy of that cabinet on my hard drive to reference. Do you know the photographer and date of photo? (just curious)

Thanks !

[bmarlowe1]

I'll email you a copy

[Joe_G.]

Thanks Mark, so it looks like a majority of the photographic images used in the set originate from Stevens Studio (Chicago) and Joseph Wood (New York). I'm surprised how many of the 1886 Joseph Wood photos of the two New York Clubs (Giants & Mets) are found in the set. The Mets would disband before Yum Yums were issued but the 1886 "Spotted Ties" are abundant with the updated team present (based on where the players wound up).

[Joe_G.]

Hope Richard doesn't mind the rampant sharing of his images, but this is cool . . .

Here is a closer look at the Joseph Wood photos found in the Yum Yum set. The Yum Yums may shed some light on what the N167 cards look like of Dorgan & Esterbrook (catalogued players but images couldn't be found for inclusion in our Old Judge book) as well as Deasley & Mutrie who may yet be found (known in woodcut form). I included two of the "Spotted Ties" for good measure as well.

Part 1 of 2 (limited to 10 images)

1886 Joseph Wood Giants
(original photos => woodcuts => N167 cards)


Connor


Corcoran


Deasley
NOTE: Not catalogued as an N167, but speculated to exist


Dorgan
NOTE: Cataloged N167, but image not available for OJ book


Esterbrook
NOTE: Cataloged N167, but image not available for OJ book


Ewing


Gillespie


Keefe


Mutrie
NOTE: Not catalogued as an N167, but speculated to exist


O’Rourke

[Joe_G.]

Part 2 of 2

Richardson


Ward
NOTE: Unlike N167 Ward with baseball cap on Yum Yum


Welch


1886 Joseph Wood "Spotted Tie" Mets


Donahue


Roseman

[Leon]

That is some neat stuff guys. Seeing those images, and knowing I owned about a half a dozen at one time or another, makes me a bit remorseful. Great photos....

[bmarlowe1]

Richard Masson has pointed out that the Cap Ansom Yum Yum is also mis-identified. He is Ned Williamson.

[Fred]

Thanks Joe!

Now you've forced me to download each and everyone of those pics you posted... there goes 10 minutes of my life....

[slidekellyslide]

The Daily/Sunday card has been known for a long time now. It is mentioned in some old price guide from the 1980s that I have packed away.

[Matt]

Great stuff Mark as always - thanks!

[barrysloate]

The Anson/Williamson error likewise has been known for a long time. However, no photo of Anson labeled Williamson has ever been found.

[Fred]

I think Dave Levin found one in the Indianapolis Find.

[barrysloate]

Yes, Dave Levin did find an N403 Williamson.

[bmarlowe1]

Anybody have a scan?

[kkkkandp]

I think Richard may have gotten his from Dave Levin.

[the-illini]

Unless I am mistaken, the only Yum Yum card found in the Indianapolis find was the Anson card depicted in this thread (which mistakenly depicts Williamson). No Yum Yum labeled as Williamson was part of the find.

[uffda51]

Here is the Wood cabinet of Dorgan. Same photo as the Yum-Yum, although the Yum-Yum is cropped.

[uffda51]

Also, the G&B Richardson uses the same photo as the Yum-Yum Richardson.

[uffda51]

I've posted my 2 Yum-Yums. No one asked, but how often do we have a Yum-Yum related thread>

[the-illini]

Here are my two!

[bmarlowe1]

Here's another one. The Tom Burns Yum-Yum is actually Lew Hardie.

[oldjudge]

Here is a better image of that composite

http://www.legendaryauctions.com/Lot...?lotid=113995#