Whats a fair price?

[Archive]

Posted By: Tim M

Obviously not a book thing..

was offered 10 or so 1915 Cracker Jacks VG/EX condition...

whats a fair offer for these to buy them all...

i want to get some more down the line and don't want to low ball,
just a fair all around deal.

any help as always is appreciated,

[Archive]

Posted By: nickinvegas

Are they Commons,semi-stars,HOF's...?

Nick

[Archive]

Posted By: Tim M

all commons except collins....thanks...

[Archive]

Posted By: Square Deal

A dealer probably wouldn't offer the person more than $200-$300 for the lot. Why not $350 or so. It's probably a fair amount for these cards. Now if the conditon is really bad then you're going to get hammered. If the condition is better than what you described then you get a better deal. Now if the cards are NrMt then you just cheated them.

Take off 10% if they claim that their grandfather gave the cards to them.

Take off 10% if it's a wife claiming to sell off her husbands cards because they need the money for his hospital care.

Take 10% off if they claim that they found them at an estate sale.

Take 10% off if they say that they found them in an attic (or wall) while remodeling.

Take 10% off if they also offer you a T206 Wagner with the cards.

[Archive]

Posted By: Chris

CJ commons if truely in this condition sell between $40 and $50.

[Archive]

Posted By: Tim M

Thanks for the input,,,

so I offered 300 for the lot including collins, got it,,,I would say they are accurately graded as high VG's...

I don't see alot of them around here so I am pleased..

thanks for the advice....it helped