Clean Sweep Auction pickups

[Brent G.]

I was lucky and no one outbid me past my bedtime. In looking for an Indianapolis card from this tough set for the past year and a half, I’d only found one beat up partial. Never thought I’d see one like this. As a long-time card player, I love the unique history of the WG1.

Any early morning winners out there?!

[gunboat82]

I overpaid for one D304 and lost several lots that I expected to win after bidding beyond my comfort zone. I'm still floored by the final prices on some of the iconic cards, and I wonder if it's a one-off or the start of a trend.

A 1932 U.S. Caramel Ruth PSA 1 went for $14,040 (very nice appeal, but still a shocking number). Another PSA Authentic punched/canceled copy went for $10,898. It's a very cool conversation piece with the boot-shaped hold punches and stamp, but the price surprised me.

A 1933 Goudey Ruth #53 PSA 1 with rounding, creasing, and toning... $11,426.

A 1933 Goudey Ruth #181 PSA 1.5 with rounding, staining, and light paper loss... $11,281.

A 1934 Goudey #37 Gehrig PSA 2 with rounding and front paper loss... $4255.

It's also worth noting that the final prices I'm using are from Clean Sweep's auction results page, and they actually understate the total price by 2%. Clean Sweep appears to be using a 20% premium to report their results, but the actual premium on the invoices is 22%.

Just crazy, crazy numbers for low-grade cards that come to auction fairly often.

[ValKehl]

Nothing for me in this auction, but based on the auction results of the 38 items on my watchlist, the prices of vintage cards are still skyrocketing. Here are 2 examples of the auction results that really surprised me:

- A 1916 M101-4 Ware's Basement 1-of-1 card of Ty Cobb in PSA 2 condition sold for $100K!

- A very rough PSA "A" Big-head strip card of Sam Rice sold for almost $1,000! Thankfully, I already have a nicer example in my Sam Rice collection.

Mike, I just checked the final prices with BP for these 2 auction items, and I found that the final prices have been correctly calculated with the 22% BP.

[pawpawdiv9]

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Nothing for me in this auction, but based on the auction results of the 38 items on my watchlist, the prices of vintage cards are still skyrocketing. Here are 2 examples of the auction results that really surprised me:

- A 1916 M101-4 Ware's Basement 1-of-1 card of Ty Cobb in PSA 2 condition sold for $100K!

- A very rough PSA "A" Big-head strip card of Sam Rice sold for almost $1,000! Thankfully, I already have a nicer example in my Sam Rice collection.

Mike, I just checked the final prices with BP for these 2 auction items, and I found that the final prices have been correctly calculated with the 22% BP.

As for the big heads- I was going after them- then I ran across another board member who started to collect them and bailed out for him- hope he got them
Now- I was interested in the 32 Carmel Ruth punched one until it passed my limit - really liked the Gehrig too
I had my eye also on the Joe Jax sport news- but also exceeded my limits
Hey- there’s another auction next week

[gunboat82]

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Mike, I just checked the final prices with BP for these 2 auction items, and I found that the final prices have been correctly calculated with the 22% BP.

Yes, it looks like the results have been updated to reflect the 22% premium.

[Yoda]

I managed to pick up the Williards Chocolate of Cobb, bought not so much for the card but for hobby history on the back: a printed stamp of famous collector Buck Barker and Buck's printing of Jefferson Burdick's last name. I still love the history of the hobby.

[gunboat82]

Did Clean Sweep announce that they started charging sales tax everywhere?

Their FAQs say tax is charged for FL, IL, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA, and WI:

7. Please note sales tax will be charged for these states, at these rates: Florida 6%, Illinois 6.25%, New Jersey 6.625%, New York 8.625%, Ohio 5.75%, Pennsylvania 6%, Virginia 4.3% and Wisconsin 5%. You may provide a resale certificate from your state.

I wasn't charged MA sales tax on my previous invoice, but I was on this one.

[Hankphenom]

Originally Posted by gunboat82

Did Clean Sweep announce that they started charging sales tax everywhere? Their FAQs say tax is charged for FL, IL, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA, and WI: I wasn't charged MA sales tax on my previous invoice, but I was on this one.

Does this mean that AHs have to maintain 50 state sales tax accounts?

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by Hankphenom

Does this mean that AHs have to maintain 50 state sales tax accounts?

Every state we pass the reporting threshold on we then have to file with that state, so theoretically yes.

[gunboat82]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Every state we pass the reporting threshold on we then have to file with that state, so theoretically yes.

In that case, Clean Sweep should definitely change their Rules/FAQs to reflect that. They also charged me sales tax on the shipping and insurance amounts, even though my state exempts shipping-related charges from the sales tax.

I suppose it's all just a rounding error when people are spending four to six figures on lots, but I tend to notice this stuff.

[Brian Van Horn]

.

[perezfan]

After many attempts over the years, I finally came away with one of these...

https://www.cleansweepauctions.com/i...tem=0000864906

[TornadoJake]

Added a 1962 Bazooka box. Ungraded, PSA has only graded one other. Price tripled on me in the final minutes, but I now have Bazooka boxes from every year except 1959 and 1964.

[ruth-gehrig]

Originally Posted by perezfan

After many attempts over the years, I finally came away with one of these...

https://www.cleansweepauctions.com/i...tem=0000864906

That thing is sweet!! Looks to be in fantastic shape and the blue mat makes it really pop!!

[Brent G.]

Originally Posted by perezfan

After many attempts over the years, I finally came away with one of these...

https://www.cleansweepauctions.com/i...tem=0000864906

GREAT piece!

[hcv123]

I was looking at a combination for stuff for potential resale as well as for my PC.
All of the resale stuff went past where I wanted to get in. Definitely some strong prices for what I would call "average" stuff.

Did really well for my PC though! :

I've been piecing together a 1910 Tip Top Pirates set - I was able to snag all but 1 (Clarke) of the ones I needed (I think a total of 12), all for what I thought were very fair if not low prices. Not sure what happened on the Clarke, but that thing landed in the stratosphere. SO I'm down to "just" Wagner and Clarke on the Tip Top set! Pretty psyched about that.

I was bidding hard on the Voskamp Carey - looking for a type card from that set - I was the underbidder unwilling to pay over $5K for that card in a PSA 1.5. As a nice consolation, I did win the Voskamp Miller - thought I paid a little to the strong side there, but hey they are rare as hens teeth.

Then I won 2 Puerto Rican winter league programs from 1953 with a pre minor league Clemente in the lineup!! These are VERY rare ( I think I've seen maybe a half dozen over the past 35+ years). As I do have an earlier example, I may make these available.

[Aaron Seefeldt]

Anybody know what the e90-1 Joe Jackson PSA 1.5 sold for? I couldn’t find it in the results

[Baseball Rarities]

Originally Posted by Aaron Seefeldt

Anybody know what the e90-1 Joe Jackson PSA 1.5 sold for? I couldn’t find it in the results

Aaron - It sold for $104K.

[bigfish]

Great auction. Very strong prices. That e90-1 Jackson was a really nice looking card. Congrats to the winners

[BRoberts]

Originally Posted by hcv123

I've been piecing together a 1910 Tip Top Pirates set - I was able to snag all but 1 (Clarke) of the ones I needed (I think a total of 12), all for what I thought were very fair if not low prices. Not sure what happened on the Clarke, but that thing landed in the stratosphere. SO I'm down to "just" Wagner and Clarke on the Tip Top set! Pretty psyched about that.

Just last week (I think) a Clarke sold for a really low price on Facebook. We're talking maybe 3x below market value. Maybe the buyer bought it to flip. At what he paid for it, you might be able to get it at a price that makes you both happy. I'll see if I can find the post.

Update: I couldn't find the exact post to post a link, but the seller was Jeff Gross / Gross Baseball Cards, who's on Net54. Maybe reach out to him and see if you can get the buyer's contact info? Hope this helps and you're down to only the Wagner soon.

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by BRoberts

Just last week (I think) a Clarke sold for a really low price on Facebook. We're talking maybe 3x below market value. Maybe the buyer bought it to flip. At what he paid for it, you might be able to get it at a price that makes you both happy. I'll see if I can find the post.

Update: I couldn't find the exact post to post a link, but the seller was Jeff Gross / Gross Baseball Cards, who's on Net54. Maybe reach out to him and see if you can get the buyer's contact info? Hope this helps and you're down to only the Wagner soon.

I saw it 15 minutes after it was posted. Messaged the guy who claimed it 5 minutes after it was posted to work out a deal who was told by Jeff that someone else bought it via PM before he posted. Also messaged Jeff - made an offer to the new owner - his response was "it seems a little light" - that was the last I heard. That example wasn't as nice as the one in CS.

I enjoy the process of assembling (isn't that what collecting is about?), more than completing and am VERY patient.

[Brent G.]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

Aaron - It sold for $104K.

If I had $104,000 to spend on a Joe Jackson, he wouldn't be wearing clown makeup. That lipstick...

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by ruth-gehrig

That thing is sweet!! Looks to be in fantastic shape and the blue mat makes it really pop!!

Thanks Michael and Brent...

I should have remembered to say thanks to Gary P of this forum, for the assist. I may not have seen it, if not for his heads-up.

[Aaron Seefeldt]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

Aaron - It sold for $104K.

Thanks Kevin.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by hcv123

I enjoy the process of assembling (isn't that what collecting is about?), more than completing and am VERY patient.

The chase is better than the catch.

[Caramelcollector]

Originally Posted by pawpawdiv9

As for the big heads- I was going after them- then I ran across another board member who started to collect them and bailed out for him- hope he got them
Now- I was interested in the 32 Carmel Ruth punched one until it passed my limit - really liked the Gehrig too
I had my eye also on the Joe Jax sport news- but also exceeded my limits
Hey- there’s another auction next week

I picked up the Baker and Rice big heads.

[BRoberts]

Originally Posted by hcv123

I saw it 15 minutes after it was posted. Messaged the guy who claimed it 5 minutes after it was posted to work out a deal who was told by Jeff that someone else bought it via PM before he posted. Also messaged Jeff - made an offer to the new owner - his response was "it seems a little light" - that was the last I heard. That example wasn't as nice as the one in CS.

I enjoy the process of assembling (isn't that what collecting is about?), more than completing and am VERY patient.

Ah, sorry you missed it. Not a surprise that numerous buyers pounced on it at that cheap price.

[Ludington1]

Congrats on the Otto Shomberg, Brent, great looking card, keep me in mind if you find another.

Darren

[Leon]

Another type card...

Williams seem to be a fair amount scarcer than Rochester.

[puckpaul]

Picked up this tough Mike Simon. Cool card. Also finally grabbed a 40 PB Joe Jackson before i can’t afford one!