Mile High Auction Lot #982 - error in description?

[ValKehl]

The description for this cabinet card states that "John McGraw" is written on the back of it: https://www.milehighcardco.com/LotDe...entoryid=61461. I don't think so - I believe the writing says "John M. (for Michael) Godar. I have asked several knowledgeable vintage collectors for their take, and they agree that the writing on the back does not say "John McGraw." So, give this item a good look if you are thinking of bidding on it.

[baseball tourist]

Def says “John M Godar”

[bigfanNY]

I read the description and it says that the cabinet was thought to belong to John M Godar who was promoted along with McGraw from Cedar Rapids. So it would make sense that his name is on back of photo. Not sure how much it affects the value?
Now if you are saying that McGraw is not pictured second from the right, Then I can see clearly how value is affected. Is that what you are saying?

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

I read the description and it says that the cabinet was thought to belong to John M Godar who was promoted along with McGraw from Cedar Rapids. So it would make sense that his name is on back of photo. Not sure how much it affects the value?
Now if you are saying that McGraw is not pictured second from the right, Then I can see clearly how value is affected. Is that what you are saying?

Jonathan, I'm not saying that McGraw is not pictured second from right. Frankly, I have not tried to determine whether it is or isn't McGraw, nor do I intend to.