Pennant guys, would love an opinion

[toyman55]

two weeks ago a jackie robinson pennnant sold on ebay for over $2300.00

Yesterday I bought one on ebay for $90.00 but would love to know if it is original. The one i bought is 21" x 8"

Here are the two pictures with the $2300.00 one and the one I bought.

thanks

[ooo-ribay]

Hopefully, Mark S. chimes in.....the one you show is not one of “the 4” Jackie Robinson pennants Mark identified. That said, your pennant DOES look vintage to me. It doesn’t say “Jackie Robinson” on it, but who else could it be?

edit: I changed my mind. Like Josh, I don’t like the font. Also, blue seems to be a felt color that is VERY susceptible to fading, yet your blue is vibrant.

[joshleland]

Thumbs down. "Dodgers" font looks more modern. Felt and especially the tassels have that Mitchell and Ness modern look. Even the shape is not right. Design wise looks strange as if lifted from the other pennant. Gut says no.

[thetahat]

I think it’s a homemade pennant, looks like poor quality control.

[vintagesportflips]

I believe it’s probably a home made pennant too. Did you by chance buy it from a Canadian seller? I ask because about a month or so ago I bought an Eagles pennant I had never seen before from a Canadian seller - when I received it I could tell it was hand painted, and likely a relatively modern handmade pennant. The seller had other similar pennants of assorted sports.

[Fballguy]

It's a homemade pennant from a scammer in Canada. I took a flyer on one last year to check it out and it was garbage. The quality of a child's crafts project.

He didn't offer returns but I messaged him stating it was garbage and I wanted a refund. He refunded immediately and said I didn't even have to sent it back. He charged me $195 for the thing, so if it was really worth anything he wouldn't have said that.

I returned it anyway.