Brad Pencil - Nice guy

A guy by the name of Brad Pencil from Illinois and or Florida just tried to sell me a T206 Cobb PSA 6 for 1/10 the retail... could this be the same one that was exposed here ? His ebay username is OLDVINTAGECARDBOARD
Who should I report this to ?
Bryan

[xplainer]

You did the right thing here. Leon can check out his info and see if he is here.

[Leon]

LOL....yes, he is a member here. He has posted 1156 times.

http://www.net54baseball.com/member.php?u=305687
.

[xplainer]

Where did this alleged sale take place? Nothing on eBay that I can see.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

A guy by the name of Brad Pencil from Illinois and or Florida just tried to sell me a T206 Cobb PSA 6 for 1/10 the retail... could this be the same one that was exposed here ? His ebay username is OLDVINTAGECARDBOARD
Who should I report this to ?
Bryan

Finally it’s a crime to be stupid !

Originally Posted by xplainer

Where did this alleged sale take place? Nothing on eBay that I can see.

Alleged? Buzz off dude I'm trying to uncover a situation here ... who should I report this to?

This guy is a member here ?! I don't see him listed under Brad Pencil are people allowed to use fake names here ? I'm verified.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

A guy by the name of Brad Pencil from Illinois and or Florida just tried to sell me a T206 Cobb PSA 6 for 1/10 the retail... could this be the same one that was exposed here ? His ebay username is OLDVINTAGECARDBOARD
Who should I report this to ?
Bryan

Was it a Cobb green?

[daves_resale_shop]

Brad seems to do a lot of business here without issue... maybe his offer was a typo.

[glchen]

I’ve purchased a lot of expensive cards from Brad and was never scammed...

[xplainer]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

Alleged? Buzz off dude I'm trying to uncover a situation here ... who should I report this to?

This guy is a member here ?! I don't see him listed under Brad Pencil are people allowed to use fake names here ? I'm verified.

Buzz off dude?
I am only asking logical questions.
Leon said he was a member here. Pencil1974.

And, don’t send me PM’s. Just post of here.

You gave his eBay name, so I guessed it happened there.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

Alleged? Buzz off dude I'm trying to uncover a situation here ... who should I report this to?

This guy is a member here ?! I don't see him listed under Brad Pencil are people allowed to use fake names here ? I'm verified.

Inspector Cluso. And if you would quit typing and click the link I added above you would find Brad's profile.

.

[1880nonsports]

but my parole officer suggested that wasn't a good thing

[orly57]

Ive conducted NUMEROUS transactions with Brad over the years and never had any issues. 10% of the price of something means one less zero. Is it possible he missed a zero?

[trobba]

Never had a problem with Brad...have done several deals with him.

[Stonepony]

Originally Posted by Leon

Inspector Cluso. And if you would quit typing and click the link I added above you would find Brad's profile.

.

Classic

[ezez420]

Takes a lot of balls to come on here and call Brad a scam artist. Brad is 100% legit. I think you should report your concern to Eric.

[xplainer]

Originally Posted by ezez420

Takes a lot of balls to come on here and call Brad a scam artist. Brad is 100% legit. I think you should report your concern to Eric.

You should see the PM’s he is sending me.

I only asked a question, now I have offended him.

And won’t post it on here for all to see.

Bryan, I won’t “ fetch” it. If you won’ t provide details, well, ok then. It is your issue to deal with.

[pencil1974]

Sorry guys this our friend Toppsaholic being a dick. What was his name, Mitch or Matt or Mike, he had several of them.

He's a bit touched and not in a good way. So if you look at the guy who is talking and just put Toppsaholics name in his place I think we have wiener.

[pencil1974]

Soooo question for you Orlando... is this basically slander then? Legal recourse?

[Sean1125]

Originally Posted by pencil1974

Sorry guys this our friend Toppsaholic being a dick. What was his name, Mitch or Matt or Mike, he had several of them.

He's a bit touched and not in a good way. So if you look at the guy who is talking and just put Toppsaholics name in his place I think we have wiener.

A bit touched? I think he got touched.

[Sean1125]

Originally Posted by pencil1974

Soooo question for you Orlando... is this basically slander then? Legal recourse?

Libel.

[orly57]

Hope they ban this guy. Better yet, I hope this thread is deleted so future google searches of Brad's name don't turn up this nonesense.

As for the libel lawsuit Brad, I'm pretty sure suing Toppsaholic would be fruitless since he probably lives in his mom's basement. At best you can garnish a couple of Phish albums, an old bong, and his bicycle.

[pencil1974]

Ok its one thing to be a bully behind the scenes, which what ever I'm cool with. But straight up on the headline is pretty ballsy lol.

Was he banned from here or did he stick around?

[aloondilana]

Brad is one of the most honest guys I know.
Have done several deals with Brad.
Never a problem.

[pencil1974]

I guess my other question is who is Brian Taylor? Shill, real person, if its a tough guy attitude, wants to fight about anything, then thats just Topps again. He gets angry quick, and probably turns green too.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by pencil1974

I guess my other question is who is Brian Taylor? Shill, real person, if its a tough guy attitude, wants to fight about anything, then thats just Topps again. He gets angry quick, and probably turns green too.

I just called Bryan Taylor's phone number on file. His voice mail picked up and he said it was him. My guess is that is this person's name. We can take it further if need be ..I wouldn't put it by a good scammer to have a fake voicemail set up. It's not that difficult. IF this OP doesn't come back and deal with it then the thread can be dealt with on it's own, I wouldn't want a troll slamming someone and having it on our board for searches. We'll see how it goes.

[pencil1974]

Yeah I would vote for troll myself but hey its a free country unless you get sued...

[Clydewally]

I have done a couple of deals with Brad without issue and with above average communication throughout.

[pencil1974]

Orlando! Dude I would gladly take all three of those items, those sound better than half the stuff I own.

[gnaz01]

Have done a couple deals of high dollar cards with Brad, he is straight up legit!!

[Rhotchkiss]

I have done deals with Brad - big boy deals - and have never had an issue. I am hoping this is just miscommunication/ a mix up.

[xplainer]

On my ignore list now.
Here and eBay.
So, overall, productive day.

Originally Posted by Sean1125

Libel.

Libel ? Hardly. Would love to see it. I can post anything that's true right counselor?
Truth can always be questioned

[pencil1974]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

I have done deals with Brad - big boy deals - and have never had an issue. I am hoping this is just miscommunication/ a mix up.

No miscommunication, I have no idea who Bryan is. A few of us have it figured out be a friend of Topps or Topps himself. Once the Libel word got tossed around though he sort of calmed down....

[orly57]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

Libel ? Hardly. Would love to see it. I can post anything that's true right counselor?
Truth can always be questioned

Did you return that missed call from Leon?

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by gnaz01

Have done a couple deals of high dollar cards with Brad, he is straight up legit!!

But did you have above average communication?

Originally Posted by pencil1974

Sorry guys this our friend Toppsaholic being a dick. What was his name, Mitch or Matt or Mike, he had several of them.



He's a bit touched and not in a good way. So if you look at the guy who is talking and just put Toppsaholics name in his place I think we have wiener.

I am not toppsaholic but I'm glad to see word of my post travels fast ! Amazed all these people here saying PENCIL is a good guy to deal with them how is he offering me a 20000 card for 2000?
People are telling me it's fake

My name is Bryan not Mitch and I am not joking about this matter. I guess I should post his correspondence? And a pic ?
Will u still doubt me then ?
This guy already sold this card once now it has reappeared I found old threads HERE ! WOW

[pencil1974]

Sure would love to see them.

Where do you live again?

[RedsFan1941]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

I have done deals with Brad - big boy deals - and have never had an issue. I am hoping this is just miscommunication/ a mix up.

ooh, i love Big Boy deals. the best is when they give you a free piece of pie with the purchase of an entree.

of course, the pie isn't really free. Big Boy makes it up with the buyer premium.

[CW]

Is the T206 Cobb still for sale?

I'll take it!

[orly57]

Bryan, I assure you that every one of us would change our position if you post convincing proof. None of us want scammers in our hobby. But please, don't just talk about the smoking gun: show it to us.

[pencil1974]

I'm interested to see it just to see his Photoshop skills. Since I use Photoshop at work I'm a bit critical but its what I get paid to do.

Originally Posted by pencil1974

Sure would love to see them.

Where do you live again?

Check my account

[pencil1974]

Originally Posted by CW

Is the T206 Cobb still for sale?

I'll take it!

You'll have to buy from Brian, I guess I just sold it too him or tried too, I don't remember now. Just call him Matt and what him get mad. Its like shaking a hornet in a glass jar.... good times...

[frankbmd]

I’m guessing Dothan.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by frankbmd

I’m guessing Dothan.

God damn you I can't stop laughing.

Originally Posted by pencil1974

No miscommunication, I have no idea who Bryan is. A few of us have it figured out be a friend of Topps or Topps himself. Once the Libel word got tossed around though he sort of calmed down....

I encourage a libel suit. You won't do it because you will be exposed.
Leon the proctor has all my info and I will make counsel available...

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

I encourage a libel suit. You won't do it because you will be exposed.
Leon the proctor has all my info and I will make counsel available...

Why all the drama? Brad said to post what you got, so don’t be a chicken $hit and just post it.......

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by gnaz01

Why all the drama? Brad said to post what you got, so don’t be a chicken $hit and just post it.......

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iM1a5D3fBAo

[pencil1974]

Originally Posted by larrydavidfan33

I encourage a libel suit. You won't do it because you will be exposed.
Leon the proctor has all my info and I will make counsel available...

Cool. I will call your bluff on this. Why don't you give me your counsels name and my friend who happens to be an attorney who is on the board but I will not mention his name will get in touch.